Carlos Duarte Costa

Carlos Duarte Costa (July 21, 1888 – March 26, 1961) was a Brazilian Catholic bishop who became the founder of the Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church, an independent Catholic church, and its international communion, which long after his death became the short-lived Worldwide Communion of Catholic Apostolic Churches.

The Most Reverend Carlos Duarte Costa
Founder of the Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church
Duarte Costa (left) with Luis Fernando Castillo Mendez (right) during the episcopal consecration in Panama
Church	Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church
Diocese	Rio de Janeiro
See	Rio de Janeiro
Installed	5 July 1945
Term ended	26 March 1961
Predecessor	Position created
Successor	Luis Fernando Castillo Mendez
Orders
Ordination	4 May 1911 by Joaquim Arcoverde de Albuquerque Cavalcanti
Consecration	8 December 1924 by Sebastião da Silveira Cintra
Rank	Considered as Patriarch (title not used during his lifetime) (Brazilian Catholic Apostolic) / Bishop - (Catholic)
Personal details
Birth name	Carlos Duarte Costa
Born	July 21, 1888 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Died	March 26, 1961 (aged 72) Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Nationality	Brazilian
Denomination	Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church (formerly Roman Catholic)
Previous post	Bishop of Botucatu (1924-1937) Titular Bishop of Maura (1937-1945) Bishop of Rio de Janeiro (1945-death)
Motto	O Senhor é a Minha Luz ("The Lord is my Light") Charitas Christi Urget Nos ("The Love of Christ Compels Us")
Coat of arms
Sainthood
Feast day	21 July (not celebrated liturgically)
Venerated in	Independent Catholicism Old Catholicism Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church Worldwide Communion of Catholic Apostolic Churches
Title as Saint	Saint Carlos of Brazil
Canonized	July 4, 1970 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil by Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church
Attributes	Gray cassock with red piping, red biretta or zucchetto, pectoral cross
Patronage	Independent Catholicism, ICAB, conscience, freedom, people in poverty, people in desperate situations

Styles of Carlos Duarte Costa
Reference style	His Excellency, The Most Reverend
Religious style	Bishop
Posthumous style	Saint

Ordination history of Carlos Duarte Costa
History Priestly ordination Date 4 May 1911 Place Uberaba, Brazil Episcopal consecration Principal consecrator Sebastião da Silveira Cintra Co-consecrators Alberto José Gonçalves Benedito Paulo Alves de Souza Date 8 December 1924 Place Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Episcopal succession Bishops consecrated by Carlos Duarte Costa as principal consecrator Salomão Barbosa Ferraz 15 August 1945 Antidio Jose Vargas 8 December 1946 Luis Fernando Castillo Mendez 3 May 1948 Milton Cunha 5 June 1960 Orlando Acre Moya 30 November 1956

The former Bishop of Botucatu,[1] he was excommunicated by Pope Pius XII, ultimately for schism, but in culmination of several doctrinal and canonical issues (such as his views on clerical celibacy). Duarte Costa has been canonized as "St. Carlos of Brazil" by the Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church and others.[2]

Early life and ministry

Carlos Duarte Costa was born in Rio de Janeiro on July 21, 1888, at the residence of his uncle Eduardo Duarte de Silva. His father was João Matta Francisco Costa and his mother was Maria Carlota Duarte da Silva Costa, who came from a family heavily involved in politics and public service.[3] He completed his primary studies at the Salesian College Santa Rosa, in Niterói, and at age nine, he received his first Communion in the cathedral of Uberaba from the hands of his uncle, Dom Eduardo Duarte da Silva (now a bishop), on July 24, 1897. That same year he was taken by his uncle to Rome to study at the Pontificio Collegio Pio Latino Americano, a Jesuit minor seminary. In 1905 he returned to Brazil for health reasons and entered an Augustinian seminary in Uberaba, where he continued his philosophical and theological studies. He only narrowly managed to complete his studies and qualify for ordination, however, and his uncle intervened to vouch for his nephew.[4]

After ordination as a deacon, Duarte Costa served in the cathedral church of Uberaba under his uncle, Dom Eduardo Duarte da Silva, who, on April 1, 1911, ordained Duarte Costa to the priesthood.[5][4] He worked with his uncle in Uberaba as secretary of the diocese. Duarte Costa was awarded the title of monsignor for his publication of a catechism for children and was later named Protonotary Apostolic and General Secretary of the Archdiocese of Rio de Janeiro, serving in this capacity until 1923.

On July 4, 1924, Pope Pius XI nominated Duarte Costa as Bishop of Botucatu.[5] His episcopal consecration occurred on December 8 that year at the metropolitan cathedral of Rio de Janeiro, presided over by Cardinal Sebastian Leme da Silveira Cintra.

Attempts at church and societal reform

In the 1930s, Duarte Costa became deeply involved in the social and political changes taking place in Brazil. Brazil's economy had collapsed in 1929 as a result of the Great Depression and a populist military regime had taken over the government in 1930. Led by Getúlio Vargas, the new government had an erratic policy record in its early years, sometimes anti-clerical and anti-aristocratic, sometimes swinging the opposite direction. In 1932, Duarte Costa became a leading spokesman for the Catholic Electoral League, which was organized by the church to lobby for Christian principles in the laws and acts of the government.

In 1932, Duarte Costa played an active role in the Constitutionalist Revolution, a failed attempt to restore constitutional government to Brazil. Duarte Costa formed a "Battalion of the Bishop" to fight on the side of the Constitutionalist troops and helped finance the battalion by selling off diocesan assets along with his own personal possessions. Duarte Costa's battalion never fought, however, which was a source of disappointment to him.[6] Duarte Costa's support for the Constitutionalist Revolution earned him the animosity of President Vargas, signaling the beginning of a long period of difficult relations between Duarte Costa and the Brazilian government.

In 1936, Duarte Costa made his second ad limina visit to Rome, meeting with Pope Pius XI. it is widely believed that he presented the Pope with a list of radical reform proposals for the Church of Brazil, though no record of this survives. During this period he did become friends with another outspoken priest who would go on to achieve world fame, Helder Camara.[7]

Bishop of Maura

In September 1937, Duarte Costa resigned from his episcopal post and was appointed titular bishop of Maura.[5] Duarte Costa left the diocesan quarters but remained in Rio de Janeiro as Bishop Emeritus of Botucatu and titular Bishop of Maura. He obtained the support of a protector, Cardinal Dom Sebastião da Silveira Cintra, who granted permission for him to keep a private chapel. At this time he established the magazine Nossos ("Ours") as a vehicle to spread devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary.

Soon, however, Duarte Costa resumed his vocal criticism of the government and the national church administration, which he saw as an accessory to the mistreatment of the poor in Brazil. He openly criticized certain papal periodicals and encyclicals, including Rerum novarum (Leo XIII), Quadragesimo anno (Pius XI), and Divini Redemptoris (Pius XI).

In 1942 several priests and nuns of German and Italian ethnicity were arrested in Brazil for operating clandestine radio transmitters, presumably passing information to the German and Italian governments. Duarte Costa publicly said that these individuals were just the tip of the iceberg, and claimed that most German and Italian clergy in Brazil were agents of the German Nazi and Italian Fascist regimes. In light of their allegedly mixed loyalties, Duarte Costa called on all German and Italian clergy to resign.[8]

In 1944 he gained further notoriety by writing a glowing preface to the Brazilian translation of The Soviet Power by the Very Reverend Hewlett Johnson, the Anglican Dean of Canterbury known as "The Red Dean" for his uncompromising support of the Soviet Union. Duarte Costa consistently maintained his left-wing allegiance, calling for the establishment of a "Christian communism" in contrast to "Roman [Catholic] Church Fascism."[9]

As long as he enjoyed the protection of Cardinal Dom Sebastiao Leme da Silveira Cintra, Duarte Costa's political activism proceeded without much trouble. However, soon after the cardinal's death, Duarte Costa was formally accused by the Brazilian government of being a communist sympathizer. He was arrested on June 6, 1944 and imprisoned[10] in Belo Horizonte. The following month the Ecclesiastical Chamber forbade him from preaching or hearing confessions, as punishment for his undisciplined outspokenness. He remained imprisoned until September 6, 1944, when he was released in response to pressure from the embassies of Mexico and the United States on his behalf.

Excommunication

After his release from prison Carlos Duarte Costa soon found himself in trouble again. In May 1945 Duarte Costa gave newspaper interviews accusing Brazil's papal nuncio of Nazi-Fascist spying, and accused Rome of having aided and abetted Adolf Hitler. In addition, he announced plans to set up his own Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church, in which priests would be permitted to marry (and hold regular jobs in the lay world), personal confessions and the praying of rosaries would be abolished and bishops would be elected by popular vote.[11]

In response to Duarte Costa's continued insubordination, the Vatican finally laid against him the penalty of excommunication on July 2, 1945. Upon being informed of his excommunication, Duarte Costa responded by saying, "I consider today one of the happiest days of my life." He immediately titled himself "Archbishop of Rio de Janeiro" and told the press that he hoped soon to ordain ten married lawyers and professional men as priests in his new church.[11]

Founding of ICAB

A few days after learning of his excommunication, Duarte Costa established the Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church (ICAB). Its articles of incorporation were published in the federal register on July 25, and the church was legally registered as a civil society. On August 18, 1945, Duarte Costas published a "Declaration to the Nation", in which he again criticized the Roman Catholic Church and promoted his new national church. Although he had already been excommunicated, on July 24, 1946, he was declared "excommunicado vitando". This effectively forbids Catholics from associating with him.

After establishing ICAB, Duarte Costa continued to use the same vestments, insignia, and rites as he had in the Catholic Church. This provoked the cardinals of São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro to appeal to the Minister of Justice and the President himself for an injunction against both him and the ICAB. On September 27, 1948, the ICAB churches were closed by the courts, on the grounds that they were deceiving the public into thinking they were Catholic churches and clergy. Duarte Costa quickly filed an appeal, and in 1949 the Supreme Court ruled that the ICAB could reopen its doors on condition that the church use a modified liturgy and its clergy wear gray cassocks to minimize the potential for confusion with the black-colored Roman Catholic clergy.[12]

With the formation of ICAB, Duarte Costa implemented a number of reforms of what he saw as problems in the Roman Catholic Church. Clerical celibacy was abolished. Rules for the reconciliation of divorced persons were implemented. The liturgy was translated into the vernacular and in emulation of a short-lived experiment in France clergy were expected to live and work amongst the people and support themselves and their ministries by holding secular employment. According to Randolph A. Brown, within a short time ICAB began to be identified as “The Church of the Poor”.[13] It attracted the attention of scholars of Brazilian religions such as Roger Bastide, who described it as “having both a religious and a political program, the latter [having] much in common with the Communist Party”.[14]

Unlike the official Catholic Church in Brazil, the ICAB developed friendly relations with Spiritism, Freemasonry. Duarte Costa “began giving talks in Spiritist centers to publicize the new church” and “ICAB would go on to attract many members” of Freemasonry.[15] Duarte Costa also “openly encouraged cooperation with Umbanda, Macumba and Candomblé communities,” at that time considered a threat and opposed by the Catholic hierarchy.[16]

Duarte Costa consecrates Castillo Mendez in 1948

In the years immediately after founding the church, Duarte Costa consecrated four bishops, Salomão Barbosa Ferraz (August 15, 1945), Jorge Alves de Souza and Antidio Jose Vargas (both in 1946) and Luis Fernando Castillo Mendez (May 3, 1948).[17] These bishops had intended to establish similar autonomous Catholic national churches in several other Latin American countries. Relations between the bishops were not always good, and Duarte Costa fought bitterly with Ferraz from the earliest days of ICAB.[18] His most fractious and quarrelsome relationship was with Luis Fernando Castillo Mendez however, whom he repeatedly denounced as a fraud and a charlatan.[19] Duarte Costa consecrated eleven ICAB bishops in total.[20]

Duarte Costa served as leader of the Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church and its international affiliates for sixteen years until his death in 1961, by which time the church in Brazil was said to have grown to 60,000 members.[13]

Death and legacy

Duarte Costa died quietly in his sleep on March 26, 1961 (Palm Sunday), in Rio de Janeiro at 72 years of age. At that time, ICAB had 50 priests and 37 bishops, with many of the congregations meeting in private homes.[21] Duarte Costa was accredited and praised by the Church for his acts of charity for the poor and his strong devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary and the Eucharist.

The bishops consecrated by Duarte Costa went on to consecrate dozens of additional bishops, many of whom had only tenuous relationships with the Brazilian Church. Bishops tracing their apostolic succession back to Duarte Costa have formed numerous other independent Catholic denominations in the United States, Europe, and Latin America, most of which have no formal ties to the Brazilian church. Bishops of the Worldwide Communion of Catholic Apostolic Churches have all been consecrated sub conditione to ensure recognition of their lineage. Many consecrated bishops also hold apostolic succession to current Old Catholic bishops.[22]

In the years since his death there have been many reports on graces and miracles resulting from people praying through Duarte Costa's intercession. On July 4, 1970, after officially acknowledging his work for the poor and the church, the Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church held a canonization Mass in Rio de Janeiro and officially granted Duarte Costa the title "São Carlos do Brasil".[23] He is considered to be the patron saint of ICAB and Independent Catholicism.

References

1. "Bishop Carlos Duarte Costa". Catholic-Hierarchy.org. David M. Cheney. Retrieved 21 January 2015.
2. "Bishop Carlos Duarte-Costa". cacina.org. Retrieved 2020-12-25.
3. Jarvis, Edward, Carlos Duarte Costa: Testament of a Socialist Bishop, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2019, pp. 30-31
4. Jarvis, Edward, God, Land & Freedom: The True Story of ICAB, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2018, p. 42
5. "Igreja Católica Apostólica Brasileira IICAB)", Encyclopedia of New Religious Movements, (Peter Clarke, ed.), Routledge, 2004 ISBN 9781134499700
6. Jarvis, Edward, God, Land & Freedom: The True Story of ICAB, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2018, pp. 46-47.
7. Jarvis, Edward, God, Land & Freedom: The True Story of ICAB, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2018, p. 49
8. "Bishop Urges Weeding Out", The New York Times, September 22, 1942
9. Jarvis, Edward, God, Land & Freedom: The True Story of ICAB, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2018, p 16
10. Byrne, Julie. The Other Catholics, Columbia University Press, 2016 ISBN 9780231541701
11. ""Rebel in Rio", Time Magazine, July 23, 1945". Archived from the original on September 12, 2012. Retrieved June 29, 2007.
12. ""Freedom of Religious Worship"". Archived from the original on 2005-03-12. Retrieved 2007-07-06. from the Brazilian Supreme Court historical website
13. "Randolph A. Brown, "A Concise History of the Western Orthodox Church in America (WOCA)"". Archived from the original on 2007-08-22. Retrieved 2007-07-18.CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
14. Roger Bastide, The African Religions of Brazil: Towards a Sociology of the Interpenetration of Civilizations, English translation of the 1960 French edition, Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2007, p. 233.
15. Jarvis, Edward, Carlos Duarte Costa: Testament of a Socialist Bishop, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2019, pp. 77–78
16. Jarvis, Edward, Carlos Duarte Costa: Testament of a Socialist Bishop, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2019, p. 59
17. Jarvis, Edward, God, Land & Freedom: The True Story of ICAB, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2018, pp 77-109
18. Jarvis, Edward, God, Land & Freedom: The True Story of ICAB, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2018, pp. 78-79
19. Jarvis, Edward, God, Land & Freedom: The True Story of ICAB, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2018, pp. 111-115
20. Jarvis, Edward, Carlos Duarte Costa: Testament of a Socialist Bishop, Apocryphile Press, Berkeley CA, 2019, pp. 197-206
21. "Carlos Duarte, 72, Led Brazil Church", The New York Times, March 27, 1961
22. http://www.cosmas.cnc.net/apos_success_duarte_costa.htm
23. "Bishop Carlos Duarte Costa and the Catholic Apostolic National Churches". Archived from the original on 2015-07-14.

External links

• Igreja Católica Apostólica Brasileira (ICAB)
• The Mexican National Catholic Church
• National Catholic Apostolic Church in the United States (non-Roman)