George Hogarth Pringle

George Hogarth Pringle
George Hogarth Pringle
Born	22 December 1830
Died	31 March 1872
Education	University of Edinburgh
Known for	Introducing Listerian antisepsis into Australia
	Medical career
Profession	Surgeon

George Hogarth Pringle (22 December 1830 – 31 March 1872) was a Scottish-Australian surgeon. He qualified in medicine from Edinburgh, Scotland and then worked in the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh along with the young Joseph Lister with whom he continued to correspond. He settled in Parramatta, New South Wales, Australia and is credited with introducing Listerian antisepsis into Australia.

Early life

George Hogarth Pringle was born at Kintail in Ross-shire, Scotland to Mary Hogarth (1803–1850) and James Hall Pringle (1801–1873) a tenant farmer at Hyndlee, near Hawick in Scottish Borders, a farm described in Walter Scott's novel Guy Mannering. It has been suggested his mother was related to William Hogarth (1697–1764) the artist and to Charles Dickens (1812–1870).[1][2][3] Examination of the relevant birth and death certificates does not reveal any obvious relationship to either.[4][5][6]

Little is known about his early years or schooling. Pringle qualified Licentiate of the Royal College of Surgeons from the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh in 1852 [7] and MD from the University of Edinburgh the same year with a thesis entitled 'Organic Stricture of the Urethra'.[8] He was appointed House Surgeon in the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh under Professor James Syme (1799–1870) and Professor James Spence (1812–1882). One of his fellow residents in the Infirmary was Joseph Lister (1827–1912) with whom he maintained a lifelong correspondence. George Hogarth Pringle left Edinburgh to serve as a Medical Officer in the Crimean War as a surgeon on a ship transporting the sick and wounded from the battlefields of the Crimean Peninsula to the base hospital at Scutari. Thereafter he worked as a ship's surgeon with the Cunard Company and then on the Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company Company's Clydebuilt ship SS Emeu[9] between Suez and Sydney.[10]

Emigration to Australia

In 1859 he settled in Parramatta in New South Wales and registered as a doctor there (number 500) that year.[11] Parramatta, now part of greater Sydney and situated at the head of the navigable part of the Parramatta river, was proclaimed a city in 1788, the year of the arrival of the first fleet. It was here that the Governor's residence was established in 1799. George Hogarth Pringle set up practice in George Street, Parramatta, succeeding a Dr Bassett. His partner, a fellow Scot Dr (later Sir) Normand MacLaurin (1835–1914), went on to become Chancellor of Sydney University. Pringle also worked with Dr Walter Brown (b1821), the first of three generations of Drs Brown to practise in Parramatta. The last of the three, Dr Keith McArthur Brown, (d1962) wrote an account of medical practice in Parramatta which includes descriptions of Pringle's work.[12] He was also visiting surgeon to the Benevolent Asylum and surgeon to the King's School and Newington College, a Wesleyan School sited at that time at Silverwater.[13]

Introduction of antiseptic surgery to Australia

George Hogarth Pringle wrote a letter to the Sydney Morning Herald published on 30 January 1868.[14] This was on ‘the treatment of compound fractures with carbolic acid by my old friend and hospital colleague Joseph Lister”, and was essentially a case report describing Pringle’s successful use of antiseptic principles for a compound fracture. He went on "Having at present under my care, what I may call a representative case of this form of treatment, the first , so far as I am aware in which it has been applied in the colony, I crave, in default of any local medical journal ..." This assertion that there was no local medical journal was not entirely correct as the Australian Medical Journal had been founded in 1856 but he may not have regarded this as ‘local’ as it was published in Melbourne. His later case reports were published in the Australian Medical Journal.[10]

Pringle's case report

He describes the treatment of a wound of the forearm sustained by the accidental discharge of a shotgun into an area some three inches above the left wrist joint: "I recommended immediate amputation" he wrote "more especially having the dread of secondary haemorrhage and lockjaw before my eyes; but neither the patient nor his relatives would consent to this, and begged for me to try to save the limb. I therefore, duly warning them of the manifold risks, resolved to try Professor Lister's plan". After wound excision, he dressed the wound with a dressing soaked in carbolic, immobilising the fracture with a fenestrated splint. He went on "Suffice to say that in dressing the arm this morning, the 34th day from receipt of the injury, I find that the whole wound has completely healed up, thus converting a compound into a simple fracture. No pus whatever has appeared ... firm union has taken place between the ends of the ulna and satisfactory progress made with the radius, perfect motion and sensibility retained in the hand". He concluded "Such are the astounding results of this method of treatment in the first case to which I have applied it. And be it remembered, this is no quack remedy, but the result of patient scientific enquiry and thought on the part of that ‘philosophical investigator’ Joseph Lister".[14]

The outcome

Pringle’s decision to publicise this case in a newspaper was criticised in subsequent correspondence to the Sydney Morning Herald.[15] The Australian surgeon Thomas B. Hugh considered that Pringle's use of surgical and anatomical terminology suggests the article was directed at a medical readership and that Pringle’s communication to the newspaper resulted in the eventual adoption of antiseptic principles by Australian doctors.[16]

Death

Pringle had visited Britain in 1870 and during this visit qualified as a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh (FRCSEd). He died, probably from dysentery, on board the sailing ship Parramatta on 31 March 1872 aged 41 while returning to Australia from a further visit to Britain and was buried at sea.[12][17] His son James Hogarth Pringle (1863–1941) returned to Britain after his father's death. He too became a surgeon and made a number of significant contributions to surgery.[18][10]

References

Smith, A. N. (1982). "Pringle's maneuver". Current Surgery. 39 (1): 12–7. PMID 7037316.
Miln DC (1963). "James Hogarth Pringle – surgeon extraordinary" (PDF). Proceedings of the Scottish Society for the History of Medicine: 30–37.
Gurey, L. E.; Swan Jr, K. G.; Swan, K. G. (2005). "James Hogarth Pringle". The Journal of Trauma. 58 (1): 201–5. doi:10.1097/01.ta.0000149331.71639.89. PMID 15674176.
Registrar General for Scotland. Statutory records of births, marriages and deaths Birth entry: George Hogarth Pringle. 1830. ref 072/00200038
Registrar General for Scotland. Statutory records of births, marriages and deaths. Death certificate :James Hall Pringle 1874 ref 892/000033D
Registrar General for Scotland. Statutory records of births, marriages and deaths. Birth entry :Catherine Hogarth 1815 ref 685/00104200047
Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh list of licentiates
Pringle, G. Hogarth (1852). "Organic stricture of the urethra". Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
ss EMEU. Clydebuilt Database
Macintyre, Iain (2008). "George (1830-72) and his son James Hogarth (1863-1941) Pringle: unsung surgical pioneers". Journal of Medical Biography. 16 (3): 155–161. doi:10.1258/jmb.2007.007037. ISSN 0967-7720. PMID 18653835.
George Hogarth Pringle. Australian Medical Pioneers Index
Brown KM. Medical Practice in old Parramatta. Sydney. Angus & Robertson. 1937
"Obituary". The Lancet. 100 (2571): 832–833. 1872. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(02)56640-X.
Sydney Morning Herald 30 January 1868.
O'Sullivan, D. M. (1967). "The introduction of antiseptic surgery to Australia". The Medical Journal of Australia. 2 (20): 896–902. PMID 4866138.
Hugh, T. B. (1995). "The beginning of antiseptic surgery in Australia". The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Surgery. 65 (12): 887–9. doi:10.1111/j.1445-2197.1995.tb00582.x. PMID 8611114.
"Births, Marriages, and Deaths". Sydney Morning Herald 10 August 1872
Gurey, Lowell; Swan, Kenneth; Swan, Keneth (2005). "James Hogarth Pringle". The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care. 58 (1): 201–205. doi:10.1097/01.TA.0000149331.71639.89. ISSN 0022-5282. PMID 15674176.