Juan R. Torruella

Juan Rafael Torruella del Valle Sr. (June 7, 1933 – October 26, 2020) was an American jurist from Puerto Rico. He served as a United States Circuit Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit from 1984 until his death, and as chief judge of that court from 1994 to 2001. He was the first and, to date, only Hispanic to serve on the First Circuit, which includes Puerto Rico.[1]

Juan R. Torruella
Chief Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
In office August 3, 1994 – June 15, 2001
Preceded by	Stephen Breyer
Succeeded by	Michael Boudin
Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
In office October 4, 1984 – October 26, 2020
Appointed by	Ronald Reagan
Preceded by	Seat established by 98 Stat. 333
Succeeded by	vacant
Chief Judge of the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico
In office September 8, 1982 – October 30, 1984
Preceded by	Hernan Gregorio Pesquera
Succeeded by	Juan Pérez-Giménez
Judge of the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico
In office December 20, 1974 – October 30, 1984
Appointed by	Gerald Ford
Preceded by	Hiram Rafael Cancio
Succeeded by	José A. Fusté
Personal details
Born	Juan Rafael Torruella del Valle June 7, 1933 San Juan, Puerto Rico
Died	October 26, 2020 (aged 87) San Juan, Puerto Rico
Education	University of Pennsylvania (BS) Boston University School of Law (JD) University of Virginia School of Law (LLM) University of Puerto Rico (MPA) Magdalen College, Oxford University (MSt)

Before becoming an appellate judge, he served as a district judge on the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico from 1974–1984. He was also a competitive sailor, competing for the Puerto Rican team at the Summer Olympic Games in 1964, 1968, 1972, and 1976.[2]

Education and career

Torruella was born in Old San Juan, on June 7, 1933, to Juan N. Torruella and Belén del Valle de Torruella.[1] His father was a dentist who became a lawyer.[1]

Torruella graduated from the Admiral Farragut Academy in Pine Beach, New Jersey.[1] He received his Bachelor of Science from the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania in 1954, his Juris Doctor from Boston University School of Law in 1957, his Master of Laws from University of Virginia School of Law in 1984, and a Master of Public Administration from University of Puerto Rico School of Public Administration in 1984.[3] His LL.M. work focused on judicial process.[4] In 2003, Torruella received a Master of Studies in modern European history from Magdalen College, Oxford.[5]

Career as a lawyer

Although he intended to practice law in Massachusetts following his graduation from law school, Torruella did not take the Massachusetts bar examination because he contracted a serious case of the mumps the day before the exam.[4] He instead returned to Puerto Rico and was admitted to the bar there.[4] He served as law clerk to Associate Justice Pedro Pimentel of the Puerto Rico Supreme Court, and then worked for three years for the National Labor Relations Board in an investigations and litigation role in Puerto Rico.[4] His practice was mostly in civil law, including admiralty, aviation, and labor law, but he also served as court-appointed counsel in some criminal cases.[4] Torruella was in private practice of law in San Juan from 1959 to 1974,[3] where he handled cases in both the federal courts and the Puerto Rico courts.[4] He first worked at the law firm of Fiddler, Gonzalez & Rodriguez for eight years, becoming a partner at the firm.[4] Torruella then became a solo practitioner, and then practiced law in partnership with Jaime Pieras, Jr., who later became a federal district judge.[4]

Federal judicial service

District court service

Torruella was nominated by President Gerald Ford on November 18, 1974, to a seat on the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico vacated by Judge Hiram Rafael Cancio. He was confirmed by the United States Senate on December 18, 1974, and received his commission two days later. He served as chief judge from 1982 to 1984. His service was terminated on October 30, 1984, due to his elevation to the First Circuit.[3]

In 1979, Torruella was the judge in various criminal trespass cases against demonstrators who entered a beach in Vieques to protest its use by the U.S. Navy. Torruella ordered that the demonstrators receive separate trials. Some defendants were sentenced to prison; others received six-month suspended sentences. Some of the demonstrators were radical pro-independence advocates and refused to acknowledge the federal court's jurisdiction or to defend themselves at trial.[6][7] The Vieques cases were the highest-profile of Torruella's cases over his decade as a district judge.[4]

Court of appeals service

Torruella was nominated by President Ronald Reagan on August 1, 1984, to the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, to a new seat created by 98 Stat. 333.[3] He was confirmed by the Senate on October 3, 1984,[3][8] by voice vote.[8] He received his commission the following day,[3] becoming the first Puerto Rican to serve on the circuit court bench.[4] José A. Fusté replaced Torruella on the district bench.[9]

Torruella served as chief judge of the First Circuit from 1994 to 2001.[3][1] Although his length of service entitled him to take senior status, Torruella chose to remain a judge on active service[10] and continued to hear cases until his death in 2020.[1]

Notable decisions and work

Torruella was consistently an advocate of Puerto Rican rights.[1] He dissented from a 2005 ruling en banc First Circuit decision that Puerto Ricans are properly denied a voice in the election of the president of the United States because Puerto Rico is not a state.[11] In August 2017, Torruella wrote a lengthy dissent when the en banc circuit rejected a lawsuit challenging Puerto Rico's exclusion from congressional apportionment.[12][13] Torruella wrote the book The Supreme Court and Puerto Rico: The Doctrine of Separate and Unequal (University of Puerto Rico: 1988), a study of the Supreme Court's decisions in the Insular Cases, in which Torruella argues that "colonial rule and the indignities of second-class citizenship can be ended not, as in the case of the Philippines, by granting the colony its independence ... but rather, by securing for Puerto Rico equality under American law" including Puerto Rican statehood.[14] The book was favorably reviewed by Judge José A. Cabranes in the Harvard Law Review.[14] In a 2018 article, Torruella argued that "Puerto Rico's colonial relationship to the United States throughout the United States' various 'experiments' with Puerto Rico and its people, although variously labeled for political purposes and constitutionally denominated an 'unincorporated territory,' has merely perpetuated the inherent inequality of the United States citizens who reside in Puerto Rico as compared to the rest of the nation, and is the major cause of the Island's economic crisis."[15]

Torruella authored the First Circuit opinion in Planned Parenthood of Northern New England v. Heed (2004), in which the court upheld the district court's decision declaring New Hampshire's "parental notification" abortion law unconstitutional, and enjoining its enforcement. The decision held that the state law was inconsistent with the Constitution and relevant Supreme Court constitutional decisions in Roe v. Wade, Stenberg v. Carhart, and Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey.[16] The case later went to the Supreme Court in Ayotte v. Planned Parenthood of Northern New England (2006).[17]

In 2009, Torruella wrote the opinion in Noonan v. Staples, Inc., allowing a suit for libel to proceed because even though the statements at issue were true they reflected "actual malice." (Under the law in Massachusetts and elsewhere in the U.S., truth is usually an absolute defense to libel, but Massachusetts law contains an exception if the defendant made the statement with "actual malice.")[18][19] Torruella's decision did not decide the question of whether this exception was inconsistent with the Constitution's First Amendment because the argument was raised too late in the proceedings.[18][19] A Harvard Law Review comment indicated that "the court's analysis serves as an indication that, had the constitutional claim been appropriately asserted, the law would not have survived."[18]

In 2012, Torruella joined a unanimous First Circuit panel decision (written by Judge Michael Boudin) in Massachusetts v. United States Department of Health and Human Services. The decision struck down section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which denied federal benefits to all same-sex couples, even those legally married under state law.[20][21]

In 2015, Torruella dissented from a First Circuit decision denying Dzhokhar Tsarnaev's request for a writ of mandamus compelling the district court to grant a change of venue of Tsarnaev's trial due to widespread pretrial publicity.[22] In July 2020, Torruella joined the opinion of Judge O. Rogeriee Thompson in vacating the federal death sentence of convicted Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, on the basis of legal errors in the sentencing proceedings. The First Circuit remanded to the district court for a new penalty phase. In a concurring opinion, Torruella wrote that he would have gone further to hold that the district court's denials of Tsarnaev's motions for change of venue were an abuse of discretion that "denied Tsarnaev the right to a fair trial and sentencing determination," given the huge media coverage of the bombing in the Boston area. Torruella cited the precedent in the trial of Timothy McVeigh for the Oklahoma City bombing, in which a change of venue to Denver was granted.[23][24][25]

Sailing career

Torruella competed for Puerto Rico in four Olympic sailing events:[2][26]

• 1964: Enoshima in the Finn (31st)
• 1968: Acapulco in the Flying Dutchman (28th)
• 1972: Kiel in the Flying Dutchman (27th)
• 1976: Kingston in the Soling (22nd)

Torruella was captain of the Puerto Rican team in each of the four Olympics.[14] He also competed in the 1975 and 1979 Pan American Games.[14] In the 1984 Summer Olympic Games in Los Angeles, Torruella served as a coach; he was informed of his appointment to the First Circuit while coaching in summer 1974.[4]

As a yachtsman, Torruella made several long-distance sea voyages, including two trans-Atlantic crossings in 1992, on the 500th anniversary of Columbus's first voyage; a few years later, Torruella undertook an 8,000-mile sailing trip across the Caribbean Sea and Panama Canal to the Pacific Ocean, where he visited the Galápagos Islands and Puerto Montt, Chile, before traveling to Buenos Aires, Argentina, via Cape Horn.[4]

Personal life and death

Torruella met his wife, Judith (Judy) Wirt in 1955 and had two sons, two daughters, eight grandchildren, and numerous great-grandchildren.[1] Torruella died on October 26, 2020, in San Juan, Puerto Rico, at the age of 87.[1]

Publications

• The Supreme Court and Puerto Rico: The Doctrine of Separate and Unequal, Río Piedras: University of Puerto Rico, 1988, ISBN 0-8477-3019-0
• "The Insular Cases: The Establishment of a Regime of Political Apartheid" (PDF), University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law, 29 (2): 284–320, 2007

See also

• List of Puerto Ricans

References

1. Sam Roberts, Juan R. Torruella, Groundbreaking U.S. Appeals Judge, Dies at 87 Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, New York Times (October 28, 2020).
2. Evans, Hilary; Gjerde, Arild; Heijmans, Jeroen; Mallon, Bill; et al. "Juan Torruella Sr". Olympics at Sports-Reference.com. Sports Reference LLC. Archived from the original on April 18, 2020. Retrieved July 2, 2012.
3. "Torruella, Juan R." Federal Judicial Center. Archived from the original on October 29, 2020. Retrieved August 1, 2017.
4. Jose A. Fuentes-Agostinia & Gustavo A. Gelpi, Jr., "Judges Profile: The Honorable Juan R. Torruella," Federal Lawyer (August 1997).
5. "Juan R. Torruella". Center for Puerto Rican Studies, Hunter College. Archived from the original on August 1, 2017. Retrieved May 27, 2017.
6. Puerto Ricans Vow to Avenge Death in U.S. Prison Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, New York Times (November 18, 1979).
7. Radicals Say Attack on Bus Is Retaliation for 3 Deaths Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, New York Times (December 4, 1979).
8. PN1037 — Juan R. Torruella del Valle — The Judiciary Archived November 26, 2018, at the Wayback Machine, 98th Congress (1983-1984), Congress.gov.
9. PN614 — Jose Antonio Fuste — The Judiciary: 99th Congress (1985-1986) Archived November 26, 2018, at the Wayback Machine, Congress.gov.
10. Ruggero J. Aldisert, A Nonagenarian Discusses Life as a Senior Circuit Judge, 14 J. App. Prac. & Process 183, 188-89 (2012).
11. Igartua-de la Rosa v. United States Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, 417 F.3d 145 (1st Cir. 2005).
12. Note, Recent Case: First Circuit Denies En Banc Petition's Claim of Nonapportionment to Puerto Rico, 131 Harv. L. Rev. 1155 (2018).
13. Igartúa v. Trump, 868 F.3d 24 (1st Cir. 2017) (mem.).
14. José A. Cabranes, Book Review: Puerto Rico: Colonialism as Constitutional Doctrine (review of The Supreme Court and Puerto Rico: The Doctrine of Separate and Unequal by Juan R. Torruella), 100 Harv. L. Rev. 450-464 (1986)
15. Juan R. Torruella, Why Puerto Rico Does Not Need Further Experimentation with Its Future: A Reply to the Notion of "Territorial Federalism", 131 Harv. L. Rev. F. 65 (January 2018)
16. Planned Parenthood v. Heed Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, 390 F.3d 53 (1st Cir. 2004).
17. Ayotte v. Planned Parenthood of N. New Eng. Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, 546 U.S. 320 (2006).
18. Note, Noonan v. Staples, Inc.: First Circuit Applies Libel Law that Does Not Allow Truth as a Defense in Cases of "Actual Malice.", 123 Harv. L. Rev. 784 (2010).
19. Noonan v. Staples, Inc. Archived December 31, 2016, at the Wayback Machine, 556 F. 3d 20 (1st Cir. 2009).
20. Lyle Denniston, DOMA ban on gay marriage falls (FINAL UPDATE) Archived August 14, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, SCOTUSBlog (May 31, 2012).
21. Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep't of Health & Human Services Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, 682 F.3d 1 (2012).
22. In re Tsarnaev, 780 F.3d 14 (1st Cir. 2015) (per curiam).
23. David Abel, Travis Andersen, Tonya Alanez and Milton J. Valencia Federal appeals court vacates Tsarnaev death sentence, orders new penalty-phase trial Archived July 31, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, Boston Globe (July 31, 2020).
24. Sean Philip Cotter & Joe Dwinell, New death sentence trial for Tsarnaev 'punch to the stomach' Archived August 3, 2020, at the Wayback Machine, Boston Herald (July 31, 2020).
25. United States v. Tsarnaev Archived October 29, 2020, at the Wayback Machine (1st Cir. 2020).
26. "Juan R. Torruella". Olympedia. Archived from the original on June 10, 2020. Retrieved June 6, 2020.

Sources

• Juan R. Torruella at the Biographical Directory of Federal Judges, a public domain publication of the Federal Judicial Center.