Lynn Ungoed-Thomas

Sir Arwyn Lynn Ungoed-Thomas (29 June 1904 – 4 December 1972) was a Welsh Labour Party politician and British judge.

Personal life

He was born on 29 June 1904, the son of Evan Ungoed Thomas, minister of Tabernacle Welsh Baptist Church, Carmarthen, for more than forty years. He was educated at Queen Elizabeth Grammar School (Carmarthen), Haileybury College and Magdalen College, Oxford. He married on 19 April 1933 to Dorothy, the daughter of Jasper Travers Wolfe of county Cork. They had two sons and one daughter [1]

Ungoed-Thomas played rugby union for Leicester Tigers in 1931, featuring in 8 games between January and March and scoring two tries.[2][3]

Career

Before his political career, he served in the army throughout World War II, where he became a major.

He was elected at the 1945 general election as Member of Parliament (MP) for the Welsh constituency of Llandaff and Barry. His seat was abolished for the 1950 general election, but shortly afterwards the Labour MP for the new Leicester North East constituency became a High Court judge, and Ungoed-Thomas was returned to Parliament in the resulting Leicester North East by-election. Between April 1951[4] and October 1951, he served as Solicitor General, and received the customary knighthood.[5]

He held the seat until resigned from the House of Commons in 1962, when he became a High Court judge, assigned to the Chancery Division. He remained on the High Court until his death in 1972.

The European Convention on Human Rights

He was a member of the British delegation to the Council of Europe, where he argued strongly for the creation of the European Convention on Human Rights. However, he opposed the creation of a Court to oversee the implementation of the Convention and to provide the protections within it. He, along with Rolin of France, proposed on 6 September 1949 that the Legal Committee's recommendation of a Court be rejected.[6] They believed that both a European Commission of Human Rights and a European Court of Human Rights were unnecessary. One of several objections they had was the proposal that individuals, not just states, could seek redress for alleged violations through the Court. Ungoed-Thomas opposed the right to individual petition because he felt that individuals could 'bring one of the States to trial even after examination and with the authority of a "sorting organization"'.[7]

After two days of debate on the issue, on 8 September 1949, Rolin and Ungoed-Thomas' amendment rejecting a European Court of Human Rights was itself rejected.[8]

Ungoed-Thomas then proposed that individuals not be allowed to petition the Commission.

"Personally I object to this right of individuals going to the Commission for this reason. I foresee shoals of applications being made by individuals who imagine that they have a complaint of one kind or another against the country ... In my opinion the objection to the Commission is as great as the objection to the Court."[9]

He was supported in this objection by the likes of Sundt of Norway who felt that the right of individual petition would open a flood of claims against signatory States.[10]

Ultimately, the right to individual petition became an optional clause, in part due to these objections raised, under the original Article 25 of the Convention. The right of individual petition has been mandatory since the adoption of a revised European Convention on Human Rights in 1998. (new Article 34).[11]

Judicial career

As a judge he is remembered for his much-cited judgement in the tax case Cheney v Conn (1968). Other notable decisions of his included:

• Butt v Kelson [1952] Ch 197 (as counsel)
• Re Golay's Will Trusts [1965] 1 WLR 969
• Cunliffe-Owen v Teather & Greenwood [1967] 1 WLR 1421, terms implied by custom
• Mann v Goldstein [1968] 1 WLR 1091
• Selangor case [1968] 1 WLR 1555
• Bushell v Faith [1970] AC 1099 (at first instance)
• Hodgson v Marks [1971] Ch 892 (at first instance)

References

1. "The National Library of Wales :: Dictionary of Welsh Biography". yba.llgc.org.uk. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
2. "K.C. to fight Leicester NE". Leicester Daily Mercury. Leicester. 22 July 1950. p. 1. Archived from the original on 15 October 2020. Retrieved 15 October 2020 – via britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk. Although Mr Ungoed-Thomas politically new to Leicester, has an old sporting association with the city He played for Leicester Tigers on several occasions after the first world war.
3. Farmer, Stuart; Hands, David. Tigers - Official history of Leicester Football Club. The Rugby DevelopmentFoundation. pp. 102&438. ISBN 978-0-9930213-0-5.
4. "No. 39218". The London Gazette. 1 May 1951. p. 2458.
5. "No. 39225". The London Gazette (Supplement). 11 May 1951. p. 2644.
6. Janis, M.W., Kay, R.S., Bradley, A.W., 2010, European Human Rights Law: Text and Materials, Oxford, pg. 16, ISBN 978-0-19-927746-9
7. Ibid.
8. Ibid.
9. Ibid. at 17
10. Ibid.
11. Ibid. at 19

• Leigh Rayment's Peerage Pages

External links

• Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by Lynn Ungoed-Thomas