Richmond Giants
The Richmond Giants were an independent semi-pro Negro league baseball team based in Richmond, Indiana that fielded a team in two different seasons. Though their existence was short, several Negro league stars played for the Giants, including Bill Holland, Connie Day, Will McMurray and Hall of Famer Oscar Charleston.
| Richmond Giants 1918–1919 Richmond, Indiana | |
| League affiliation(s) | |
|---|---|
| |
| Ballpark(s) | |
|
The founding of the Giants
A split in the ranks of the ABCs
Just before the 1916 baseball season, an irreconcilable dispute between Indianapolis ABCs co-owners C.I. Taylor and Thomas Bowser broke out, which ultimately caused the club to split into two different factions, with each respective owner forming their own team. Since neither owner wanted to yield the 'ABCs' moniker to the other, the teams were quickly dubbed 'Taylor's ABCs' and 'Bowser's ABCs' by the press. Taylor's ABCs played most of their home games at Federal League Park, while Bowser's ABCs kept Northwestern Park for their home field.
After the 1916 season, Bowser sold his team to Indianapolis-based Black businessman Warner Jewell, who owned and operated a pool hall. The team was then known as 'Jewell's ABCs' for the 1917 season. After the Federal League Park in Indianapolis was demolished after the 1916 season, it forced both ABCs teams, as well as the white Indianapolis Indians, a minor league club, to share just two available ball fields (Washington Park and Northwestern Park). The arrangement was disastrous for Jewell's club, who consistently found themselves third on the pecking order for the two fields, severely affecting their gate receipts.
After the 1917 season, Jewell pledged his ABCs would commit themselves to a barnstorming existence for the 1918, opting to play only road games rather than battle two more talented and better-funded teams for a spot on the either of Indianapolis' premier diamonds. The result was disastrous; lopsided losses and no-shows marred Jewell's short-run at a barnstorming-only schedule. By late May 1918, Jewell's club had seemed to quietly disband.[1]
Jewell's ABCs find home at Richmond's Exhibition Park
While Jewell's club couldn't find a home field, the exact opposite issue faced baseball organizers in Richmond, Indiana in 1918. The city had built Exhibition Park, a $12,000, 2,500-seat stadium in 1917 to house the minor league Richmond Quakers of the Central League. Due to attendance issues and a dramatic player shortage caused by World War I, the Central League cancelled the 1918 season, leaving no team to play in the stadium that was barely a year old.
Jewell, paired with Richmond businessman George Brehm, seized the opportunity to forge a partnership, making Exhibition Park the home field for Jewell's ABCs the remainder of the season, and made the announcement official on June 2, 1918. The team, initially called the 'Richmond ABCs', would soon be renamed the Richmond Giants. The roster was cobbled together quickly, and was an amalgamation of Jewell's ABCs, Taylor ABCs, or other former players in the Indianapolis area who were available for the weekend games. Given the quick roster composition, some players (such as the case with McMurray, traditionally a catcher, or Day, who would become a second baseman) played out of position.[2]
1918 Season
1918 Richmond Giants roster
| Name | Position | Age | Previous Team(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Robert Prior | P | 26 | Louisville White Sox, Chicago Union Giants, Jewell's ABCs |
| William 'Specks' Webster | C | 22 | St. Louis Stars, Jewell's ABCs |
| George Board | 1B | 37 | Indianapolis ABCs |
| Otis 'The Cat' Francis | 2B | 27 | Indianapolis ABCs, Chicago Union Giants |
| James 'Home Run' Lynch | 3B | 29 | French Lick Plutos, West Baden Sprudels, Indianapolis ABCs, Jewell's ABCs |
| Connie Day | SS | 20 | Jewell's ABCs |
| Jack 'The Fighting Poor Boy' Hannibal | LF | 27 | Louisville White Sox, Indianapolis ABCs, Jewell's ABCs |
| Oscar Charleston | CF | 21 | Indianapolis ABCs, New York Lincoln Stars, Royal Poinciana Hotel |
| Will McMurray | RF | 36 | St. Paul Gophers, St. Louis Stars, West Baden Sprudels |
| Reserves | Position | Age | Previous Team(s) |
| Arthur Coleman | P | 20 | None |
| Bill Holland | P | 17 | None |
| Will Jones | C | 21 | Louisville White Sox, Chicago American Giants, Chicago Giants |
| Elzie McReynolds | P/1B | 23 | Bowser's ABCs |
| Charles Cooper | OF | unknown | Only known Richmond native on team |
Meet the Giants
Largely playing opposition from larger cities such Indianapolis, Muncie, Anderson, Dayton, and Springfield, the Giants posted a 10-5-2 (.647) record on the season. The Giants scored 94 runs (5.7 runs/game) while yielding only 57 to their opposition (3.4 runs/game).
The Giants played almost exclusively all-white teams, except for the July 28, 1918 game against the Springfield Mints. The Mints were managed by Chappie Johnson, a Negro leagues mainstay whose career had begun with the Page Fence Giants in 1895. The team became synonymous with Johnson, and even was sometimes referred to as the 'Springfield Chappies' during the 1918 season. The Giants defeated the Mints 16-7 in a shortened five-inning game.
The day after beating the Mints and running their season record to 6-1, the local newspaper, the Palladium-Item, wrote that "with Charleston, Lynch, and Jones batting every pitcher all over the field the colored boys seem capable of taking on some of the bigger semi-pro teams in the state with the brand of ball the colored [sic] put up along with their amusing pranks, the club seems to have come to stay."[3]
Highlights of the season included the double-play combination of shortstop Connie Day, second baseman Otis Francis, and first baseman George Board, with Day in particular drawing heaps of praise, including the Palladium-Item's appraisal that "Day’s playing at shortstop was a feature as it always is. Day is undoubtedly one of the greatest shortstops in minor league baseball today and he could make a few big leaguers go some to outshine him."[4]
In addition to Day's defense, James Lynch hit no fewer than four home runs in the short season.
Outfielder and sometimes-pitcher Jack "The Fighting Poor Boy" Hannibal also proved immensely popular with the fans. The Indianapolis-based Hannibal was also a prolific boxer, and had appeared in Richmond the previous May in a bout against Christy Williams, also known as "Dayton's Dark Secret." It was alleged that out of one hundred professional fights in his career, he only lost five.[5]
The debut of Bill 'Devil' Holland
The Giants were scheduled to end their 1918 campaign during the Labor Day holiday weekend with consecutive doubleheaders on September 1 and 2. With four games to play in approximately twenty-four hours, and their pitching ranks thinned by injury, the Giants enlisted the help of seventeen-year-old right-handed pitcher Bill Holland, an Indianapolis-based sandlot pitcher.
Holland would face the Muncie Valentines on September 1, a team with multiple former minor league prospects, and the Richmond Athletics on September 2, the city's all-star team. In his debut against the Valentines, Holland hurled a complete game one-hitter, striking out eleven hitters in a 6-1 Giants victory. The next day, he pitched an 11-inning compete game against the Athletics. Though he allowed only four earned runs and struck out thirteen hitters, the Giants lost 7-6.
1919 season
The Giants, buoyed by 1918 standouts Holland, Day, McMurray, Lynch, Francis, Elzie McReynolds, and William Webster, returned to Richmond the next season. They played two games (one on May 11, the other June 6, 1919), splitting the pair with a 1-1 record. Holland started both games on the mound, striking out thirteen hitters in the first game, a 1-0 victory, and tossed a complete game one-hitter in a 1-0 loss.
In late June 1919, they merged with the Kokomo, Indiana-based Kokomo Black Devils to form a new team, the 'Hoosier Giants'. They disbanded at the end of the 1919 season.
When the Negro National League was formed in 1920, seven former Giants found teams in the new league. Connie Day, Otis Francis, and Oscar Charleston were signed by the Indianapolis ABCs, Will Jones by the Chicago Giants, Bill Holland by the Detroit Stars, while Arthur Coleman and Will Webster both appeared with the Dayton Marcos. Third baseman James Lynch appeared with the Marcos in 1926, the team's second stint in the NNL.
All-time results
| 1918 | Opponent | Result/Score |
|---|---|---|
| June 9 | Richmond Athletics | W 6-2 |
| June 16 | Indianapolis Merrits | W 4-1 |
| June 23 | Anderson Panhandles | W 6-2 |
| July 4 | Farmland Nine | L 4-3 |
| July 14 | Dayton Rubbers | W 3-0 |
| July 21 | Dayton Aviators | W 13-2 |
| July 28 | Springfield Mints | W 16-7 |
| August 4 | Farmland Nine | L 12-4 |
| August 11 | Farmland Nine | L 2-0 |
| August 18 | Liberty Red Sox | W 5-4, T 3-3 |
| August 25 | Piqua Coca-Colas | W 9-1, W 6-0 |
| September 1 | Muncie Valentines | W 6-1, T 4-4 |
| September 2 | Richmond Athletics | L 7-6, L 6-3 |
| Total | 10-5-2 (.647) | |
| 1919 | Opponent | Result/Score |
| May 11 | Richmond Athletics | W 1-0 |
| June 6 | Farmland Nine | L 1-0 |
| Total | 1-1 (.500) | |
| Overall Total | 11-6-2 (.632) |
References
- Muncie Star Press, May 5, 1918
- Richmond Item, June 2, 1918
- Palladium-Item, July 29, 1918
- Palladium-Item, August 26, 1918
- "Jack Hannibal boxing career summary accessed through Agate Type". Retrieved July 30, 2020.