1915 Dunedin Central by-election

The Dunedin Central by-election of 1915 was a by-election during the 19th New Zealand Parliament held on 3 February in the Dunedin Central electorate. The by-election was sparked by the resignation of the incumbent, Charles Statham,[1] after irregularities in the counting of the vote during the 1914 general election turned a 10-vote lead for his competitor Jim Munro into a 12-vote loss. There were only two nominees.

1915 Dunedin Central by-election

3 February 1915
Turnout	7,959 (84.55%)
Candidate Charles Statham Jim Munro Party Reform United Labour Popular vote 4,033 3,926 Percentage 50.67% 49.33%
Member before election Charles Statham Reform Elected Member Charles Statham Reform

Background

On election night 1914 Jim Munro had a provisional lead of one vote in Dunedin Central. Due to the closeness of the polling there were several re-counts of the ballots which took many days. To general surprise the final magisterial re-count resulted in the seat being awarded to Charles Statham by a 12 vote margin. It was soon revealed however that this was due to a "careless" polling clerk scribbling notes and numbers on ballot papers (rather than counterfoil). All affected ballot papers just happened to be votes for Munro and were thus declared void. If included the 22 disqualified votes would have resulted in a 10 vote final victory for Munro.[2]

Under the circumstances Statham felt honour bound to resign the seat, though he was in no way obligated to do so. He did and thereby triggered a by-election. The Reform government had a bare minimum majority and therefore much was at stake. As a result the Liberal Party did not contest the election and its leader Sir Joseph Ward actively toured the electorate to encourage the electors to vote for Munro. In the event of a Labour victory it was conceivable for Ward to form a minority government with Labour support.[2]

Results

The following table gives the election results:

1915 Dunedin Central by-election[3]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Reform	Charles Statham	4,033	50.67	+0.59
	United Labour	Jim Munro	3,926	49.33	-0.62
Informal votes			11	0.13	-2.53
Majority			107	1.34	+1.18
Turnout			7,959	84.55	+2.97
Registered electors			9,413

Results by locality

Following table showcases the detailed results by locality by ballot location:

Locality	Statham (Reform)		Munro (ULP)
	Votes	%	Votes	%
Baptist Hall	200	48.54	212	51.46
Berwick's Store	192	55.98	151	44.02
Caversham	153	40.58	224	59.42
Council Chambers	630	59.15	435	40.85
Green Island Church	66	33.84	129	51.16
High Street School	191	79.91	48	20.09
Kirkland Hall	256	39.26	396	64.64
Methodist Church	146	60.08	97	39.92
Odd Fellows' Hall	150	26.64	413	73.35
Old Council Chambers	152	51.17	145	48.83
Russell Street	251	56.27	195	43.73
Victoria Hall	819	46.45	944	53.55
Walker Street	629	58.45	447	41.55
Absentees & Seamen	186	64.58	102	35.42
Total	4,033	50.67	3,926	49.33

Aftermath

As a result of Statham's victory, the government retained its scant 41:39 majority, allowing them to continue in office. At the next general election in 1919 Statham once again defeated Munro. Statham was to remain MP for Dunedin Central until he retired at the 1935 general election. Munro won election to Parliament at another by-election in 1922 for the neighboring seat of Dunedin North.

Notes

1. Scholefield 1950.
2. Bassett 1982, p. 18.
3. Hislop, J. (1915). The General Election, 1914. National Library. pp. 1–33. Retrieved 1 August 2013.

References

• Bassett, Michael (1982). Three Party Politics in New Zealand 1911–1931. Auckland: Historical Publications. ISBN 0-86870-006-1.
• Scholefield, Guy (1950) [First ed. published 1913]. New Zealand Parliamentary Record, 1840–1949 (3rd ed.). Wellington: Govt. Printer.