1984 United States Senate election in Texas

The 1984 United States Senate election in Texas was held on November 6, 1984. Incumbent Republican U.S. Senator John Tower decided to retire, instead of seeking a fifth term. Republican Phil Gramm won the open seat.

1984 United States Senate election in Texas

November 6, 1984

Nominee Phil Gramm Lloyd Doggett Party Republican Democratic Popular vote 3,111,348 2,202,557 Percentage 58.6% 41.4%

County results Gramm:      50–60%      60–70%      70–80%      80–90% Doggett:      50–60%      60–70%      70–80%      80–90%

U.S. senator before election John Tower Republican Elected U.S. Senator Phil Gramm Republican

Democratic primary

Candidates

• Lloyd Doggett, State Senator from Austin since 1975
• Kent Hance, U.S. Representative from Lubbock since 1979
• Bob Krueger, former U.S. Congressman from New Braunfels
• Harley Schlanger
• Robert Sullivan
• David Young

Campaign

The primary was 45% Hispanic, but included many moderate to conservative voters. Hance positioned himself as the most moderate to conservative candidate, who co-sponsored President Ronald Reagan's tax package.[1] Doggett was the more liberal candidate, attacking Reaganomics and getting endorsements from the Texas teachers' union and Agriculture Commissioner Jim Hightower.[2] Doggett's campaign manager was James Carville.[3] Krueger was seen as the front runner and was a moderate who supported the state's oil and gas industry, but had close ties with the Hispanic community because he was Spanish-speaking.[4] Hance attacked both Kroeger and Doggett for supporting amnesty for illegal aliens and supporting gay rights.[5] The initial primary was extremely close between the top three candidates. Each candidate got 31% of the electorate. Hance ranked first, only 273 votes ahead of Doggett and 1,560 votes ahead of Krueger.

Since no candidate passed the 50% threshold, Hance and Doggett qualified for the run-off election. Hance fired his pollster despite ranking first.[6] Krueger endorsed fellow U.S. Congressman Hance, saying "Ultimately, the quality of one's public service depends upon the character that one displays in filling an office."[7][8] In the June election, Doggett very narrowly defeated Hance by just 1,345 votes.

Results

Initial election on May 5, 1984

May Democratic primary[9]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Democratic	Kent Hance	456,446	31.2%
	Democratic	Lloyd Doggett	456,173	31.2%
	Democratic	Robert Charles Krueger	454,886	31.1%
	Democratic	David Young	47,062	3.2%
	Democratic	Robert S. Sullivan	34,733	2.4%
	Democratic	Harley Schlanger	14,149	1.0%

Run-off election on June 2, 1984

June Democratic primary[10]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Democratic	Lloyd Doggett	491,251	50.1%
	Democratic	Kent Hance	489,906	49.9%

Republican primary

Candidates

• Phil Gramm, U.S. Representative from College Station since 1979
• Hank Grover, State Senator and former State Representative from Houston
• Ron Paul, U.S. Representative from Lake Jackson (1976–77, 1979–85)
• Robert Mosbacher Jr., Houston oil businessman

Campaign

The primary was a highly competitive, multimillion-dollar contest.[11] Gramm recently switched parties in 1983, but he was a conservative who supported Reaganomics. Gramm spent $4 million.[12]

Results

May Republican primary[13]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	Phil Gramm	247,280	73.3%
	Republican	Ron Paul	55,771	16.5%
	Republican	Robert A. Mosbacher Jr.	26,250	7.8%
	Republican	Hank Grover	8,055	2.5%

General election

Candidates

• Lloyd Doggett (D), State Senator
• Phil Gramm (R), U.S. Congressman

Results

General election results[14]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	Phil Gramm	3,111,348	58.6%
	Democratic	Lloyd Doggett	2,202,557	41.4%
Total votes			5,313,905	100.00%
	Republican hold

See also

• 1984 United States Senate elections

References

1. "Conservative Holds Lead In Texas Senate Primary". The New York Times. 1984-06-03. Retrieved 2018-09-21.
2. "The Victoria Advocate - Google News Archive Search". google.com.
3. McKinnon, Mark (November 1, 1966). "The Spin Doctor Is Out". Texas Monthly. Retrieved February 9, 2020.
4. "Kentucky New Era - Google News Archive Search". google.com.
5. "Mid Cities Daily News - Google News Archive Search". google.com.
6. "The Bonham Daily Favorite - Google News Archive Search". google.com.
7. AP (1984-06-01). "CAMPAIGN ; Krueger Backs Hance In Democratic Runoff". The New York Times. Retrieved 2018-09-21.
8. "The Victoria Advocate - Google News Archive Search". google.com.
9. "Our Campaigns - TX US Senate - D Primary Race - May 05, 1984". ourcampaigns.com.
10. "Our Campaigns - TX US Senate - D Runoff Race - Jun 02, 1984". ourcampaigns.com.
11. "Daily Times - Google News Archive Search". google.com.
12. "The Victoria Advocate - Google News Archive Search". google.com.
13. "Gramm Voices Surprise". The Victoria Advocate. May 6, 1984.
14. "Our Campaigns - TX US Senate Race - Nov 06, 1990". ourcampaigns.com.