Charlestown Elevated

The Charlestown Elevated was a segment of the MBTA Orange Line rapid transit line that ran from the Canal Street Incline in downtown Boston, Massachusetts through Charlestown to a terminal in Everett, Massachusetts. It opened in June 1901 and was replaced by the Haymarket North Extension in April 1975.

Charlestown Elevated
An Orange Line train on the Charlestown Bridge in 1967
Overview
Termini	Canal Street Incline Everett station
Stations	5
Service
System	BERy Main Line / MBTA Orange Line
History
Opened	June 10, 1901[1]
Closed	April 4, 1975[1]
Technical
Number of tracks	2
Track gauge	4 ft 8 ^1⁄2 in (1,435 mm)
Route map Everett Mystic River Sullivan Square Thompson Square City Square Charles River Atlantic Avenue Elevated North Station Canal Street Incline Tremont Street subway (1901-1908) Washington Street subway (1908-1975)

Route

The Charlestown Elevated began at the Canal Street Incline, just north of Haymarket Square in the Bulfinch Triangle section of downtown Boston, Massachusetts. It paralleled the Causeway Street Elevated north to North Station just south of Boston Garden. There it turned east along Causeway Street to Tower C, the split with the Atlantic Avenue Elevated, then north over the Charlestown Bridge.[2]

The Elevated turned slightly with an elevated station at City Square, then followed Main Street through Charlestown with a station at Thompson Square. Sullivan Square, the original terminal, was a grand arched brick building with multiple streetcar loops. The Sullivan Square Shops, one of the line's two maintenance facilities, was located just north of Sullivan Square. From there, the line turned northeast and crossed the Mystic River on a high bridge, then slowly descended to the ground-level Everett station.

History

Construction

A test train on the Canal Street Incline in April 1900

Building of the elevated began in 1899 and it opened for revenue service on June 10, 1901.[1][3] Stations were located at North Union Station (soon renamed as North Station), City Square, and Sullivan Square, with a major maintenance facility at Sullivan Square. The Atlantic Avenue Elevated opened on August 22, 1901, connecting to the Charlestown Elevated east of North Station.[1] Thompson Square opened as an infill station between City Square and Sullivan Square on May 22, 1902.[1]

When the Causeway Street Elevated was built in 1912, a platform was built at North Station for Atlantic Avenue Elevated shuttle trains so they would not block the main tracks.[1] In 1917, the elevated was slated to be replaced with a more permanent subway line along the same Main Street routing, but this project was canceled by the US's entry into World War I.[4]

Everett extension

In the 1910s and 1920s, the Boston Elevated Railway (BERy) had plans to extend the Charlestown Elevated to Malden, and the southern portion of this extension, including a drawbridge over the Mystic River, was built in the late 1910s. Everett station was opened in an isolated industrial area just north of the river crossing on March 15, 1919.[1] Intended to be temporary and to be used only until full service to Malden was implemented, it was constructed of wood like a house rather than a permanent transit station. The light-duty construction style of this station was unique on the Elevated.[5] Due to opposition from Malden residents who preferred a tunnel due to the noise and vibration of the planned elevated line, the Malden extension was not built and Everett remained the terminus.[5]

The Atlantic Avenue Elevated operated only as a shuttle from South Station to the 1912-built North Station platform after 1928, and closed completely on September 30, 1938.[1] It was demolished in 1942 to provide steel for the war effort, though a short section was left from Tower C for laying over trains from the Charlestown Elevated.

Replacement and closure

An Orange Line train at Sullivan Square Shops in 1967

Unlike the Washington Street Elevated, which was built as the same time with a similar design, the Charlestown El was located very near Boston Harbor and the Mystic River tidal estuary, and was thus continually exposed to accelerated corrosion caused by salt air. The elevated was also unpopular with many local residents, as it was noisy and blocked out sunlight to Main Street. In 1965, a promised removal of the elevated structure was part of a compromise deal by Edward J. Logue to secure local support of a planned redevelopment project.[6]

A replacement elevated was thus infeasible, while a full-length replacement tunnel would have been too expensive. Instead, the Haymarket North Extension project consisted of a tunnel segment from Haymarket through a new underground stop at North Station, then under the Charles River to a portal near Bunker Hill Community College. From there the extension was built along the Haverhill Line commuter rail right of way, lowering land acquisition difficulties. The Charlestown Elevated was closed at the end of afternoon rush hour service on April 4, 1975, and the Haymarket North Extension opened on April 7.[1]

The Charlestown Elevated's infrastructure was demolished shortly after its closure. By the end of 1975, only North Station and Sullivan Square stations were standing in their original locations; they were demolished in 1976.[7] Thompson Square station was lowered to the ground for restaurant use, but burned in 1976 before conversion could take place.[8][9] The footings of the Mystic River bridge, just west of the Route 99 (Alford Street) road bridge, were not removed and remain extant as of 2015. The elevated supports can also be seen in the center span of the Charlestown Bridge. Tower C, which was located at the split between the Charlestown Elevated and the Atlantic Avenue Elevated at the southern end of the Charlestown Bridge, was moved to the Seashore Trolley Museum.[10]

Station listing

City/Neighbourhood	Station	Image	Notes
Boston	North Station		Second-floor connection to Boston Garden[10]
Boston/Charlestown	City Square
	Thompson Square
	Sullivan Square		Replaced in 1975 by modern ground-level station
Everett	Everett		Terminus

References

1. Belcher, Jonathan (27 June 2015). "Changes to Transit Service in the MBTA district 1964-2015" (PDF). NETransit. Retrieved 27 November 2015.
2. Chasson, George Jr. (1987). Lonto, Arthur J. (ed.). "Boston's Main Line El: The Formative Years 1879-1908". Headlights. Electric Railroader's Association. 49.
3. "Charlestown Postcards". MIT. Retrieved 25 December 2011.
4. Stone, Kenneth (21 March 2011). "What if the El Came Down in 1917?". Charlestown Patch. Retrieved 12 May 2013.
5. Cheney, Frank; Sammarco, Anthony Mitchell (2000). When Boston Rode the EL. Arcadia Publishing. ISBN 978-0-7385-0462-9. Retrieved 26 May 2015.
6. Kennedy, Lawrence W. (1992). Planning the City Upon a Hill: Boston since 1630. University of Massachusetts. p. 188. ISBN 0870237802.
7. Eleventh Annual Report of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority. Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority. 1977. p. 12 – via Internet Archive.
8. Giordano, Kathleen Whelan (26 July 2011). "The Removal of the "El"". Charlestown Patch. Retrieved 16 January 2016.
9. "Fire destroys converted train station". Berkshire Eagle. 21 April 1975. p. 17 – via Newspapers.com.
10. "Main Line Elevated Photos". Celebrate Boston. Retrieved 29 December 2011.

External links

• Remains visible from Route 99 on Google Maps Street View
• Historic Charlestown photos