James Colledge Pope

James Colledge Pope, PC (June 11, 1826 – May 8, 1885) was a land proprietor and politician on Prince Edward Island (PEI), Canada. He served as premier of the colony from 1865 to 1867, and from 1870 to 1873. He was premier of PEI in 1873 when the island joined Canadian confederation.

James Pope
Premier of Prince Edward Island
In office 1865–1867
Monarch	Victoria
Lieutenant Governor	George Dundas
Preceded by	John Hamilton Gray
Succeeded by	George Coles
In office 1870–1872
Monarch	Victoria
Lieutenant Governor	Sir Robert Hodgson
Preceded by	Robert Haythorne
Succeeded by	Robert Haythorne
1st Premier of Prince Edward Island
In office 1873–1873
Monarch	Victoria
Lieutenant Governor	Sir Robert Hodgson
Preceded by	Robert Haythorne (colonial)
Succeeded by	Lemuel Owen
Leader of the Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island
In office 1865–1873
Preceded by	John Hamilton Gray
Succeeded by	Lemuel Owen
Member of the Canadian Parliament for Prince County
In office 1873–1874 Serving with James Yeo
Preceded by	None
Succeeded by	Stanislaus Francis Perry
Member of the Canadian Parliament for Queen's County
In office 1876–1882 Serving with Peter Sinclair (1876–1878) Frederick de St Croix Brecken (1878–1882)
Preceded by	David Laird
Succeeded by	Louis Henry Davies & John Theophilus Jenkins
Personal details
Born	June 11, 1826 Bedeque, Prince Edward Island
Died	May 18, 1885 (aged 58) Summerside, Prince Edward Island
Nationality	Canadian
Political party	Prince Edward Island Conservative
Other political affiliations	Conservative
Spouse(s)	Eliza Pethick ​ (m. 1852)​
Relations	Joseph Pope (father), William Henry Pope (brother)
Children	8
Occupation	Entrepreneur, landed proprietor, shipowner, and land agent
Profession	Politician
Cabinet	Minister of Marine and Fisheries (1878–1882)

He was born in Bedeque, Prince Edward Island, the son of Joseph Pope and Lucy Colledge. Pope was a successful businessman who was at one point the island's third largest shipowner. He entered PEI politics in 1857 when the island was still a colony of the United Kingdom. He was a member of the Conservative Party, and defended the rights of landowners against growing demands by tenant farmers for land reform.

Pope was named to the Executive Council in 1859, joining the Conservative government of Edward Palmer. In 1865, he became Premier after a dispute over Canadian confederation resulted in Palmer and John Hamilton Gray resigning from the Executive Council. While not hostile to confederation, Pope did not agree with the terms set by the Quebec Conference. A particular problem was the unresolved land question, which pitted the demands of tenant farmers for land reform against demands by landlords for compensation. The question had led to violence, and, in 1865, Pope used soldiers to put down disturbances led by the Tenant League. The next year, his government negotiated the purchase of the large Cunard estate, which composed 15% of the island's land mass, in order to redistribute the land to over 1,000 tenants. The colony lacked the funds to purchase all the island's proprietary estates.

Pope was in Britain during the London Conference (on the question of Confederation) of 1867, and persuaded delegates to agree to $800,000 being allocated by the federal treasury to buy proprietary lands on PEI so that they could be distributed to tenants. This was seen as bribery on the island, however, and divided the Tories, leading to their defeat in the 1867 election at the hands of the Liberals, who were more hostile to confederation. The Tories were also hurt by their reputation as being pro-landlord: the Tenant League campaigned to defeat the Pope government.

Pope returned to the premiership in 1870 leading a coalition government of Conservatives and Liberals. The question of school funding and the role of separate schools divided the province and both political parties, and caused the fall of Robert Poore Haythorne's Liberal government. Pope was able to form a coalition between his Tories and dissident Liberals by promising not to act on the question of schools, or confederation, before an election. The new government instead moved to commence the construction of a railway on the island in 1871. The railway proved to be a severe economic burden that almost bankrupted the island. The government lost a by-election on the railway issue, and Pope, as a result, lost his governing majority in the House of Assembly, and was forced to resign in 1872.

The financial crisis caused by the railway, and the ability of the Canadian government to bail the island out, was a major factor in the colony finally agreeing to seek to join Canadian confederation. The Liberal government of Robert Poore Haythorne sent a delegation to Ottawa, Ontario in February 1873 seeking terms to admission to Canada. Ottawa agreed to take over the railway, provide funds to settle the land question, assume the colony's debts and give the new province an annual subsidy. The Liberals called an election on the proposal. Pope's Tories argued that the terms were not good enough, and that, if elected, his government would obtain more favourable conditions. Pope's party won 20 out of 30 seats in the April election, and he proceeded to Ottawa where he persuaded the Canadian government to increase the promised annual subsidy to PEI by a further $25,000.

PEI entered confederation on July 1, 1873. Pope's third stint as Premier ended in September 1873 when he won a seat in the House of Commons of Canada. He did not run in the 1874 federal election, however, and returned to the province's House of Assembly in 1875, although he did not return to government. In 1876, he lost his seat in the provincial election which was fought on the issue of school funding and particularly separate schools. Pope's position was considered too moderate for voters who supported a secular system. The next year, he returned to the House of Commons and served as Minister of Marine and Fisheries from 1878 to 1882 in the Conservative government of Sir John A. Macdonald.

References

• "James Colledge Pope". Dictionary of Canadian Biography (online ed.). University of Toronto Press. 1979–2016.
• James Colledge Pope – Parliament of Canada biography