Kyle Duncan (judge)

Stuart Kyle Duncan (born 1972) is a United States Circuit Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

Kyle Duncan
Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Assumed office
May 1, 2018
Appointed byDonald Trump
Preceded byW. Eugene Davis
Personal details
Born
Stuart Kyle Duncan

1972 (age 48–49)
Baton Rouge, Louisiana, U.S.
EducationLouisiana State University (BA, JD)
Columbia Law School (LLM)

Biography

Duncan received his Bachelor of Arts summa cum laude from Louisiana State University and his Juris Doctor from the Paul M. Hebert Law Center at Louisiana State University, where he was inducted into the Order of the Coif and served as executive senior editor of the Louisiana Law Review. Duncan subsequently earned a Master of Laws from Columbia Law School.[1][2]

After graduating from law school, Duncan clerked for Louisiana-based Circuit Judge John M. Duhé Jr. of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.[2]

From 2008 to 2012, Duncan served as Appellate Chief for Louisiana's Attorney General's office. Some media have incorrectly stated that Duncan served as Solicitor General of Louisiana during his time at the Attorney General's office, but the title of Solicitor General did not yet exist during the time that Duncan worked there.[3] From 2012 to 2014, Duncan served as general counsel of the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, where he managed Becket's nationwide public-interest litigation.[4] He has been a member of the Federalist Society since 2012.[5]

Duncan spent four years as an assistant professor of law at the University of Mississippi Law School. He also spent two years as an associate-in-law at Columbia University Law School, three years as an Assistant Solicitor General in the Office of the Solicitor General in the Texas Attorney General's Office, and one year in the appellate practice group at Vinson & Elkins LLP.[4]

Duncan has argued two cases before the Supreme Court of the United States, and has acted as lead counsel in numerous other cases in that Court, including Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., 134 S.Ct. 2751 (2014), in which he successfully led litigation challenging the Affordable Care Act's contraceptive mandate on behalf of Hobby Lobby stores.[1]

Before becoming a judge, Duncan practiced at the Washington, D.C., firm of Schaerr Duncan LLP, where he was a partner alongside Gene Schaerr and Stephen S. Schwartz.

Federal judicial service

On September 28, 2017, President Donald Trump announced his intent to nominate Duncan to an undetermined seat on the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.[1] On October 2, 2017, he was officially nominated to the seat vacated by Judge W. Eugene Davis, who took senior status on December 31, 2016.[6] On November 29, 2017, a hearing was held on his nomination before the Senate Judiciary Committee.[7]

On January 3, 2018, his nomination was returned to the President under Rule XXXI, Paragraph 6 of the United States Senate.[8] On January 5, 2018, President Donald Trump announced his intent to renominate Duncan to a federal judgeship.[9] On January 8, 2018, his renomination was sent to the Senate.[10] On January 18, 2018, his nomination was reported out of committee by a party-line 11–10 vote.[11] Duncan's nomination was generally opposed by Democrats and supported by Republicans.[12][13][14] On April 23, 2018, the Senate voted to invoke cloture on Duncan's nomination by a vote of 50–44.[15] On April 24, 2018, his nomination was confirmed by a vote of 50–47.[16] He received his judicial commission on May 1, 2018.

Notable cases

Duncan wrote for the court in In Re: Larry Swearingen, No. 19-20565, denying the fourth habeas corpus petition and a delay of execution for Larry Swearingen, who was convicted of the 1998 murder of Melissa Trotter.[17] While Swearingen maintained his innocence, Duncan stated that the latest petition did not meet the requirements for a federal habeas corpus petition. The latest appeal was made based upon two letters from Brady Mills, director of the Texas crime lab. Mills' first letter noted that the criminologist used the terms "unique" and "to the exclusion of others" to describe the piece of pantyhose found in Swearingen's home matching the piece of pantyhose used to murder Trotter. Mills noted this was "common language throughout the forensic community, at the time" but would not be used today. Mills' second letter addressed the testimony regarding blood found under Trotter's fingernails that did not match Swearingen's as being a product of contamination. The letter stated that the blood could have been from contamination but also could have been evidence. The court noted that these "'new' claims in this latest phase could not possibly have made any difference to the outcome of his trial" and have "not come close to establishing that 'no reasonable fact-finder' would have found him guilty."[18][19] Following a failed petition to the U.S. Supreme Court, Swearingen was executed by the State of Texas on August 22, 2019.[18]

In United States v. Norman Varner, Duncan denied a pro se motion to change the name on the judgment from Norman Varner to Kathrine Nicole Jett.[20] The opinion attracted attention for also rejecting a request to refer to Varner with feminine pronouns, and going at length into perceived problems with granting such a request. Judge James L. Dennis, a Clinton appointee, dissented and wrote that Duncan misconstrued the motion. In Dennis's view, it was merely a polite request that this specific proceeding use Varner's pronouns, usually granted as a courtesy; not an overarching demand requiring six pages of obiter dictum about the threat of courts being forced to use custom pronouns everywhere. Dennis also wrote that there was no need to rule on the matter at all.[20][21] The ruling attracted attention from LGBT advocates, who saw it as confirmation of their warnings about Duncan prior to his confirmation as a judge.[21][22]

Duncan penned the court's opinion in Hill v. Washburne[23] regarding Albert Hill III's challenge to the validity of his late father Albert Hill Jr.'s will. Hill III is the great-grandson of late Texas oil tycoon H.L. Hunt and had previously agreed to a nine-figure settlement in exchange for not contesting the will of his father, Hill Jr.[24] This is one of many challenges resulting from the estate of H.L. Hunt, who died in 1974, and the fifth challenge to the Hill Jr./Hill III settlement agreement.[25][26][27][23] Hill III's sisters asked the court to enforce the settlement agreement and permanently enjoin any challenges to their father's will, the district court agreed.[24] Hill III challenged the district court's injunction but Duncan and the Fifth Circuit affirmed the injunction and remanded the case to the district court to determine if Hill III's sisters are entitled to additional costs and fees.[23][28]

Duncan penned the Fifth Circuit's April 2020 opinion granting mandamus to uphold an order by Texas Governor Greg Abbott that temporarily banned abortions during the coronavirus pandemic.[29]

See also

References
  1. President Donald J. Trump Announces Eighth Wave of Judicial Candidates" White House, September 28, 2017 This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
  2. Broach, Drew (September 29, 2017). "Meet the newest judge nominees for New Orleans federal courts". The Times-Picayune. Retrieved December 21, 2017.
  3. "Kyle Duncan, nominee for the U.S. 5th Circuit, says he held a prominent, historic job in Louisiana. There's just one small problem. – The Bayou Brief". www.bayoubrief.com.
  4. "Kyle Duncan – Nominee to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit". Vetting Room. November 27, 2017. Retrieved December 21, 2017.
  5. "Questionnaire for Judicial Nominees" (PDF). judiciary.senate.gov. Retrieved June 30, 2018.
  6. ""Eight Nominations Sent to the Senate Today" White House, October 2, 2017".
  7. "Nominations – United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary". www.judiciary.senate.gov.
  8. "Congressional Record". www.congress.gov.
  9. "President Donald J. Trump Announces Renomination of 21 Judicial Nominees".
  10. "Nominations Sent to the Senate Today".
  11. "Results of Executive Business Meeting – January 18, 2018, Senate Judiciary Committee" (PDF).
  12. "Rep. Hanabusa Opposes Judicial Confirmation of Anti-LGBT Nominee". Maui, Hawaii: Big Island Now. March 8, 2018.
  13. Broach, Drew (April 24, 2018). "Kyle Duncan confirmed in tight Senate vote for 5th Circuit Court judgeship". nola.com. Retrieved May 1, 2019.
  14. Stole, Bryn (April 24, 2018). "Star in conservative legal circles, Baton Rouge's Kyle Duncan confirmed to Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals".
  15. "U.S. Senate: U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 115th Congress – 2nd Session". United States Senate.
  16. "U.S. Senate: U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 115th Congress – 2nd Session". United States Senate.
  17. "In Re: Larry Swearingen, No. 19-20565 (5th Cir. 2019)". Justia Law. Retrieved September 23, 2019.
  18. Jackman, Tom (August 21, 2019). "Larry Swearingen, who claimed science excluded him as killer, is executed by Texas". Washington Post. Retrieved September 23, 2019.
  19. Jackman, Tom (August 17, 2019). "Did faulty science, and bad testimony, bring Larry Swearingen to the brink of execution?". Washington Post. Retrieved September 23, 2019.
  20. United States v. Norman Varner
  21. Fitzsimmons, Tim (January 16, 2020). "Trump-appointed judge dismisses trans defendant's chosen pronouns". NBC News. Retrieved January 16, 2020.
  22. Marcus, Ruth (January 19, 2020). "We're at war over gender pronouns. Can't we all just show some respect?". The Washington Post. Retrieved January 24, 2020.
  23. "Hill v. Washburne, No. 18-11633 (5th Cir. 2020)". Justia Law. Retrieved February 11, 2020.
  24. February 05, Angela Morris |; PM, 2020 at 05:05. "Left Nothing by Tycoon Father, Albert Hill is Now on the Hook for Hefty Attorney Fees". Texas Lawyer. Retrieved February 11, 2020.
  25. "Hunt vs. Hunt: The Fight Inside Dallas' Wealthiest Family". D Magazine. Retrieved February 11, 2020.
  26. Hethcock, Bill (July 31, 2015). "Exclusive: Oil heir Al Hill III asks U.S. Supreme Court to hear $41M lawyer fee dispute". www.bizjournals.com. Retrieved February 11, 2020.
  27. Peppard, Alan. "Oil in the Family". Vanity Fair. Retrieved February 11, 2020.
  28. "Fifth Circuit Tells Albert G. Hill III to Stop Challenging His Father's Will". D Magazine. February 7, 2020. Retrieved February 13, 2020.
  29. Conradis, Brandon (April 7, 2020). "Appeals court sides with Texas on abortion restrictions amid pandemic". TheHill. Retrieved April 11, 2020.
Legal offices
Preceded by
W. Eugene Davis		 Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
2018–present		 Incumbent
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.