Mac and Charlie Die
"Mac and Charlie Die (Part 1 & 2)" is the fifth and sixth episodes of the fourth season of the FX sitcom It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia. The two-part episode was written by Charlie Day, Glenn Howerton, and series creator Rob McElhenney, and directed by Fred Savage and Matt Shakman. In the episode, Mac and Charlie fake their deaths and go into hiding after Mac's vengeful father, Luther, is released from prison.
| "Mac and Charlie Die" | |
|---|---|
| It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia episode | |
| Episode no. | Season 4 Episode 5 & 6 |
| Directed by | Fred Savage (Parts 1 and 2) Matt Shakman (Part 1) |
| Written by | Charlie Day Glenn Howerton Rob McElhenney |
| Production code | IP04003 IP04004 |
| Original air date | October 2, 2008 |
| Guest appearance(s) | |
Gregory Scott Cummins as Luther | |
Plot
Part 1
After Mac and Charlie fail to frame Mac's father Luther (Gregory Scott Cummins) for threatening them at his parole hearing, Luther is released on parole. Fearing that he will seek out vengeance on them, Mac and Charlie agree that the only way to avoid Luther's wrath is to fake their deaths. The two proceed to steal Dee's car and her purse and crash the car into a brick wall to stage their apparent suicide, although Mac is injured when he fails to jump out of the car before it hits the wall. After failing to blow up the car using a hand grenade and a pistol, the two decide that they went far enough and go into hiding on the rooftop of Paddy's Pub.
Meanwhile, a glory hole is discovered in the men's bathroom stalls at Paddy's. Dennis is intrigued by the hole and the experience of anonymous sex. Frank proceeds to take Dennis to an orgy, but he is left unimpressed and disgusted at the age and shape of the participants. Back at Paddy's, an eyehole is then installed atop of the glory hole between the stalls. While Frank and Dennis are discussing potential scenarios while using the hole, Dee shows up and informs the two that Mac and Charlie are apparently dead. They play a suicide tape discovered at the scene but then proceed to argue over the perceived ridiculous demand made in Mac's will. As the three argues, Mac and Charlie listen atop of the roof.
Part 2
A memorial is held for Mac and Charlie at Paddy's, with only Mac and Charlie's mothers and the rest of the gang attending, while Mac and Charlie watch through the air ducts. While Frank mourns, Dee believes that Mac and Charlie are still alive. Commuting on a bus after her car was destroyed, Dee sees Mac and Charlie on the streets and confronts them on Paddy's rooftop later that night. Mac reveals to her that his father has been released from prison and that she would have to fake her death to avoid Luther as well.
Meanwhile, Dennis is eager to move on from on Mac and finds a new roommate Jan (Keir O'Donnell), a mysterious European. He promises Dennis extravagant European-style sex parties and brings two German women in underwear to party at the apartment. Mac and Charlie watch from the outside, with Mac becoming jealous of how fast Dennis has moved on from him. The two later witness Frank coping with losing Charlie by using a mannequin lookalike. Meanwhile, Dee attempts to fake her death by telling Dennis she's going on a jog alone by herself at night, but is ignored by Dennis.
Mac, Charlie, and Dee meet up at Paddy's and retreat to the back office when Dennis and Jan enter with a group of women to hold an anonymous sex party at Paddy's; Frank enters with the Charlie mannequin as well. Furious at Dennis having fun without them, Mac, Charlie, and Dee decide that they will scare them by pretending to be ghosts. Jan tells Dennis that he has arranged for Dennis to use the glory hole. Dennis is excited, only for him to find out that Jan had arranged for him and Frank to use the hole. The two men proceed to kick Jan and the girls out of the bar, disgusted at Jan's arrangement. Mac, Charlie, and Dee then enter the bar with firecrackers to scare Frank and Dennis, but Dennis reveals that he knew they weren't dead because he was able to hear them speaking and see them through the windows, and was only getting a new roommate to annoy Mac. Charlie then expresses concern that Luther may be still coming after them, but Frank reads a letter left by Luther on Paddy's door: he had fled to Tijuana and asks Mac to stay away from him as far as possible.
Reception
The episode received acclaim from critics and is widely considered to be one of the best episodes in the series. Donna Bowman of The A.V. Club gives both Part 1 & 2 "A" ratings, calling the episodes "solid gold" and praised its "brilliant invention and utter crudity"[1] Seth Amitin, in a review for IGN, called the episode the best of the season and says that the jokes in the episode were "all hilarious".[2]
In a 2015 ranking of the 20 Best It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia episodes, "Mac and Charlie Die" was ranked at No.1 by Rolling Stone.[3]
