SO(10)

In particle physics, SO(10) refers to a grand unified theory (GUT) based on the spin group Spin(10). The shortened name SO(10) is conventional[1] among physicists, and derives from the Lie group SO(10), which is a special orthogonal group that is double covered by Spin(10).

The pattern of weak isospin, W, weaker isospin, W', strong g3 and g8, and baryon minus lepton, B, charges for particles in the SO(10) model, rotated to show the embedding of the Georgi–Glashow model and Standard Model, with electric charge roughly along the vertical. In addition to Standard Model particles, the theory includes 30 colored X bosons, responsible for proton decay, and two W' bosons.

The pattern of charges for particles in the SO(10) model, rotated to show the embedding in E6.

History

Before the SU(5) theory behind the Georgi–Glashow model [2] , Harald Fritzsch and Peter Minkowski, and independently Howard Georgi, found that all the matter contents are incorporated into a single representation, spinorial 16 of SO(10). However, it is worth noting that Georgi found the SO(10) theory just a few hours before finding SU(5) at the end of 1973.[3]

Important subgroups

It has the branching rules to [SU(5)×U(1)_χ]/Z₅.

${\displaystyle 45\rightarrow 24_{0}\oplus 10_{-4}\oplus {\overline {10}}_{4}\oplus 1_{0}}$

${\displaystyle 16\rightarrow 10_{1}\oplus {\bar {5}}_{-3}\oplus 1_{5}}$

${\displaystyle 10\rightarrow 5_{-2}\oplus {\bar {5}}_{2}.}$

If the hypercharge is contained within SU(5), this is the conventional Georgi–Glashow model, with the 16 as the matter fields, the 10 as the electroweak Higgs field and the 24 within the 45 as the GUT Higgs field. The superpotential may then include renormalizable terms of the form Tr(45 ⋅ 45); Tr(45 ⋅ 45 ⋅ 45); 10 ⋅ 45 ⋅ 10, 10 ⋅ 16* ⋅ 16 and 16* ⋅ 16. The first three are responsible to the gauge symmetry breaking at low energies and give the Higgs mass, and the latter two give the matter particles masses and their Yukawa couplings to the Higgs.

There is another possible branching, under which the hypercharge is a linear combination of an SU(5) generator and χ. This is known as flipped SU(5).

Another important subgroup is either [SU(4) × SU(2)_L × SU(2)_R]/Z₂ or Z₂ ⋊ [SU(4) × SU(2)_L × SU(2)_R]/Z₂ depending upon whether or not the left-right symmetry is broken, yielding the Pati–Salam model, whose branching rule is

${\displaystyle 45\rightarrow (15,1,1)\oplus (6,2,2)\oplus (1,3,1)\oplus (1,1,3)}$

${\displaystyle 16\rightarrow (4,2,1)\oplus ({\bar {4}},1,2).}$

Spontaneous symmetry breaking

The symmetry breaking of SO(10) is usually done with a combination of (( a 45_H OR a 54_H) AND ((a 16_H AND a ${\displaystyle {\overline {16}}_{H}}$) OR (a 126_H AND a ${\displaystyle {\overline {126}}_{H}}$)) ).

Let's say we choose a 54_H. When this Higgs field acquires a GUT scale VEV, we have a symmetry breaking to Z₂ ⋊ [SU(4) × SU(2)_L × SU(2)_R]/Z₂, i.e. the Pati–Salam model with a Z₂ left-right symmetry.

If we have a 45_H instead, this Higgs field can acquire any VEV in a two dimensional subspace without breaking the standard model. Depending on the direction of this linear combination, we can break the symmetry to SU(5)×U(1), the Georgi–Glashow model with a U(1) (diag(1,1,1,1,1,-1,-1,-1,-1,-1)), flipped SU(5) (diag(1,1,1,-1,-1,-1,-1,-1,1,1)), SU(4)×SU(2)×U(1) (diag(0,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,-1,-1)), the minimal left-right model (diag(1,1,1,0,0,-1,-1,-1,0,0)) or SU(3)×SU(2)×U(1)×U(1) for any other nonzero VEV.

The choice diag(1,1,1,0,0,-1,-1,-1,0,0) is called the Dimopoulos-Wilczek mechanism aka the "missing VEV mechanism" and it is proportional to B−L.

The choice of a 16_H and a ${\displaystyle {\overline {16}}_{H}}$ breaks the gauge group down to the Georgi–Glashow SU(5). The same comment applies to the choice of a 126_H and a ${\displaystyle {\overline {126}}_{H}}$.

It is the combination of BOTH a 45/54 and a 16/${\displaystyle {\overline {16}}}$ or 126/${\displaystyle {\overline {126}}}$ which breaks SO(10) down to the Standard Model.

The electroweak Higgs and the doublet-triplet splitting problem

The electroweak Higgs doublets come from an SO(10) 10_H. Unfortunately, this same 10 also contains triplets. The masses of the doublets have to be stabilized at the electroweak scale, which is many orders of magnitude smaller than the GUT scale whereas the triplets have to be really heavy in order to prevent triplet-mediated proton decays. See doublet-triplet splitting problem.

Among the solutions for it is the Dimopoulos-Wilczek mechanism, or the choice of diag(0,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,-1,-1) of <45>. Unfortunately, this is not stable once the 16/${\displaystyle {\overline {16}}}$ or 126/${\displaystyle {\overline {126}}}$ sector interacts with the 45 sector.[4]

Content

Matter

The matter representations come in three copies (generations) of the 16 representation. The Yukawa coupling is 10_H 16_f 16_f. This includes a right-handed neutrino. One may either include three copies of singlet representations φ and a Yukawa coupling ${\displaystyle <{\overline {16}}_{H}>16_{f}\phi }$ (the "double seesaw mechanism"); or else, add the Yukawa interaction ${\displaystyle <{\overline {126}}_{H}>16_{f}16_{f}}$ or add the nonrenormalizable coupling ${\displaystyle <{\overline {16}}_{H}><{\overline {16}}_{H}>16_{f}16_{f}}$. See seesaw mechanism.

The 16_f field branches to [SU(5)×U(1)_χ]/Z₅ and SU(4) × SU(2)_L × SU(2)_R as

${\displaystyle 16\rightarrow 10_{1}\oplus {\bar {5}}_{-3}\oplus 1_{5}}$

${\displaystyle 16\rightarrow (4,2,1)\oplus ({\bar {4}},1,2).}$

Gauge fields

The 45 field branches to [SU(5)×U(1)_χ]/Z₅ and SU(4) × SU(2)_L × SU(2)_R as

${\displaystyle 45\rightarrow 24_{0}\oplus 10_{-4}\oplus {\overline {10}}_{4}\oplus 1_{0}}$

${\displaystyle 45\rightarrow (15,1,1)\oplus (6,2,2)\oplus (1,3,1)\oplus (1,1,3)}$

and to the standard model [SU(3)_C × SU(2)_L × U(1)_Y]/Z₆ as

${\displaystyle {\begin{aligned}45\rightarrow &(8,1)_{0}\oplus (1,3)_{0}\oplus (1,1)_{0}\oplus \\&(3,2)_{-{\frac {5}{6}}}\oplus ({\bar {3}},2)_{\frac {5}{6}}\oplus \\&(3,1)_{\frac {2}{3}}\oplus ({\bar {3}},1)_{-{\frac {2}{3}}}\oplus (1,1)_{1}\oplus (1,1)_{-1}\oplus (1,1)_{0}\oplus \\&(3,2)_{\frac {1}{6}}\oplus ({\bar {3}},2)_{-{\frac {1}{6}}}.\\\end{aligned}}}$

The four lines are the SU(3)_C, SU(2)_L, and U(1)_B−L bosons; the SU(5) leptoquarks which don't mutate X charge; the Pati-Salam leptoquarks and SU(2)_R bosons; and the new SO(10) leptoquarks. (The standard electroweak U(1)_Y is a linear combination of the (1,1)₀ bosons.)

Proton decay

• These graphics refer to the X bosons and Higgs bosons.
• 
  Dimension 6 proton decay mediated by the X boson ${\displaystyle (3,2)_{-{\frac {5}{6}}}}$ in SU(5) GUT
• 
  Dimension 6 proton decay mediated by the X boson ${\displaystyle (3,2)_{\frac {1}{6}}}$ in flipped SU(5) GUT

Note that SO(10) contains both the Georgi–Glashow SU(5) and flipped SU(5).

Anomaly free from local and global anomalies

It has been long known that the SO(10) model is free from all perturbative local anomalies, computable by Feynman diagrams. However, it only becomes clear in 2018 that the SO(10) model is also free from all nonperturbative global anomalies on non-spin manifolds --- an important rule for confirming the consistency of SO(10) grand unified theory, with a Spin(10) gauge group and chiral fermions in the 16-dimensional spinor representations, defined on non-spin manifolds.[5][6]

See also

• Flipped SO(10)

Notes

1. Langacker, Paul (2012). "Grand unification". Scholarpedia. 7 (10): 11419. Bibcode:2012SchpJ...711419L. doi:10.4249/scholarpedia.11419.
2. Georgi, Howard; Glashow, Sheldon (1974). "Unity of All Elementary-Particle Forces". Physical Review Letters. 32 (8): 438. Bibcode:1974PhRvL..32..438G. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.32.438. S2CID 9063239.
3. This story is told in various places; see for example, Yukawa-Tomonaga 100th Birthday Celebration; Fritzsch and Minkowski analyzed SO(10) in 1974.
4. • J.C. Baez, J. Huerta (2010). "The Algebra of Grand Unified Theories". Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 47 (3): 483–552. arXiv:0904.1556. doi:10.1090/S0273-0979-10-01294-2. S2CID 2941843.
5. Wang, Juven; Wen, Xiao-Gang (1 June 2020). "Nonperturbative definition of the standard models". Physical Review Research. 2 (2): 023356. arXiv:1809.11171. Bibcode:2018arXiv180911171W. doi:10.1103/PhysRevResearch.2.023356. ISSN 2469-9896. S2CID 53346597.
6. Wang, Juven; Wen, Xiao-Gang; Witten, Edward (May 2019). "A New SU(2) Anomaly". Journal of Mathematical Physics. 60 (5): 052301. arXiv:1810.00844. Bibcode:2019JMP....60e2301W. doi:10.1063/1.5082852. ISSN 1089-7658. S2CID 85543591.