2017 Gorakhpur hospital deaths
Many child deaths occurred at the state-run BRD Medical College hospital in Gorakhpur city of Uttar Pradesh, India in 2017. As of 2 September 2017, 1,317 children had died at the hospital in 2017. The 2017 deaths attracted national attention in August, when 63 children died at the hospital after the hospital's piped oxygen supply ran out.[1] The number of child deaths in previous years were 5,850 in 2014; 6,917 in 2015; and 6,121 in 2016.[2]
 Location of Gorakhpur district in Uttar Pradesh | |
| Time | 2017 |
|---|---|
| Location | BRD Medical College, Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh, India |
| Coordinates | 26°48′44″N 83°24′3″E |
| Deaths | 1,317 (as of September 2017) |
Acute encephalitis syndrome (AES) was a major cause of the deaths: As of 29 August 2017, 175 children had died because of encephalitis (including 77 in August alone).[3]
Medical negligence arising from the shortage of oxygen supply was discovered to have been a major cause for avoidable deaths. The oxygen supply was cut by the supplier due to long non-payment of dues. The state government had ignored repeated requests for clearing the dues despite warning about supply being cut. One year after the incident, the families of the victims had not been compensated or visited by state government officials.[1][4]
Child deaths
The BRD Medical College hospital is one of the biggest government hospitals in Uttar Pradesh to have specialized facility to treat neo-natal and pediatric encephalitis. It has seen a number of child deaths since 1978, when the first encephalitis outbreak in the Gorakhpur region. During 1978–2017, around 25,000 children have died of encephalitis.[5]
As of 3 September 2017, 1,317 children had died in the hospital during 2017. The number of deaths has sharply declined compared to the previous years.[2]
| Year | Children admitted | Total child deaths | Child deaths per day |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | 51,018 | 5,850 | 16 |
| 2015 | 61,295 | 6,917 | 19 |
| 2016 | 60,891 | 6,121 | 17 |
| 2017 (Till 2 Sep) | Not available | 1,317 | 5.3 |
As of 2 September 2017, the month of August saw the highest number of deaths (325):[2]
August deaths
On 6 April, the hospital's oxygen supplier, Puspha Sales wrote a letter to the Chief Minister, Adityanath, and Health Minister reminding them that the hospital's dues were unpaid and that the supply would be discontinued unless they were paid. On 3 June 2017, Pushpa Sales wrote to the Principal of the Medical College, Rajiv Mishra, Principal Secretary in the UP government, Anita Bhatnagar Jain, the Director General of Medical Education (DGME) in the UP government, K. K. Gupta, the superintendent in charge at BRD Medical College, the head of the pediatrics department, Dr Mahima Mittal, and the district magistrate, Rajeev Rautela reminding them of the unpaid dues and the fact that Encephalitis patients, who would increase with the rainy season, require 24 hours supply of oxygen. Pushpa Sales wrote 20 letters to Rajiv Mishra about the unpaid dues. Mishra in turn, wrote ten letters to the UP government about the same, and even raised the issue in a video conference with the DGME, principal secretary and district magistrate. On 30 July, Pushpa Sales sent a legal notice to the Principal, giving them until 14 August to clear dues. Oxygen ran out in the plant in the early hours of 11 August.[1]
Starting on 10 August 2017, 30 children died within 48 hours: 17 children in the neo-natal ward, five in the AES (acute encephalitis syndrome) ward and eight in the general ward.[6]
According to a 10-page letter written by Dr. Kafeel Khan in prison he received a Whatsapp message on the night of 10 August informing him of the oxygen supply cut. He said that he called the head of department, the principal and acting principal of B.R.D., the district magistrate of Gorakhpur, the chief medical superintendent of Gorakhpur and B.R.D. Medical College, and his other colleagues to inform them of the situation. He said that he also called local oxygen supplier agencies and begged them to immediately arrange for oxygen cylinders at BRD, and called nearby hospitals. He narrated that he went out to buy oxygen cylinders himself. He was able to scrape 250 cylinders together, paying for them himself and promising the suppliers that he would arrange for the rest of the payment soon. He carried some in his car and arranged with the DIG of Police for a truck and manpower from the Armed Border Force to deliver the others.[7]
Oxygen supply was restored by 2:15 AM on 13 August.[1]
| Date | Number of deaths | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NICU | AES | Non-AES | Total | |
| 7 August[8] | 4 | 2 | 3 | 9 |
| 8 August[8] | 7 | 3 | 2 | 12 |
| 9 August[8] | 6 | 2 | 1 | 9 |
| 10 August[8] | 14 | 3 | 6 | 23 |
| 11 August[8] | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 |
| 12 August[6] | 11 | |||
| 13 August[6] | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| Total | 72[6] | |||
Investigation
The hospital's principal RK Mishra was suspended on 12 August by the Government of Uttar Pradesh for "negligent behaviour" after which he resigned.[9] On 13 August, the head of encephalitis ward at the hospital, Kafeel Khan, was removed as the nodal officer.[10] The state government claimed that no deaths had occurred due to oxygen shortage.[1]
A probe report by the Gorakhpur district administration identified oxygen deprivation as the reason for the death of the children admitted to the encephalitis and neonatal wards between 10 and 11 August, but refrained from blaming the Uttar Pradesh government for the tragedy. It charged the doctors, paramedical staff and clerks of the medical institution with criminal negligence, while maintaining that the state government was unaware of the situation. It accused institute principal Rajiv Mishra of failing to alert the medical education and health departments to the impending oxygen crisis despite being aware of it. It demanded strict action against Pushpa Sales for stopping oxygen supply and accused Dr Satish Kumar, a member of the BRD Medical College Hospital's purchase committee, of going on leave from 11 August without taking Mishra's permission. Kumar was additionally charged with failing to get a faulty air-conditioner installed at the encephalitis ward repaired on time.[11] It also found overwriting in the log book related to purchase and re-filling of oxygen cylinders.[12]
A three-member technical team appointed by the central government found that 8 of 12 senior resident posts lie vacant, that only three of 31 nurses are trained to handle newborns, that poor parents are forced to buy disposables and consumables, and that the most basic infection control norms like washing hands and use of disinfectants were not being followed.[13]
Nine people were arrested in the case until August 2018. They were:
- Manish Bhandari, owner of Pushpa Sales who dealt with oxygen
- Dr Kafeel Khan, doctor in the paediatric ward
- Dr Satish, nodal officer for liquid oxygen
- Dr Rajiv Misra, principal of the medical college
- Dr Purnima Shukla, wife of Dr Rajiv Misra
- Gajanand Jaiswal, pharmacist
- Uday Pratap Sharma, Sanjay Kumar Tripathi and Sudhir Kumar Pandey (junior clerks and technical staff).
Of these, Manish Bhandari, Dr Kafeel Khan, Dr Satish, Dr Rajiv Misra and Dr Purnima Shukla had been given bail, while the others remained in jail. None of the top government officials who also had responsibility came under investigation.[1]
The investigation has been criticized.[14]
Reactions
On 12 August, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's office said he is "constantly monitoring" the situation with Minister of State Health Anupriya Patel and the Union Health Secretary.[15] In his Independence Day speech on 15 August, Modi expressed sympathy for the affected families, while calling the episode a 'natural calamity'. Siddharth Nath Singh, the Health Minister of Uttar Pradesh, denied a lack of oxygen was the cause of the deaths[16] He said that such deaths are common in August. Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath ordered a probe into the incident. He visited the hospital on 13 August 2017.[17]
The Indian National Congress (INC) demanded a separate probe monitored by the Supreme Court of India.[18] It also demanded Chief Minister, Adityanath's resignation. However, BJP President, Amit Shah dismissed this demand, saying, that such deaths were common during Congress rule too, and that action would be taken on the basis of investigation, the results of which would be made public.[19]
On 14 August, Pushpa Sales, the oxygen supplier to the hospital, released a statement that it never stopped the supply of oxygen cylinders despite the outstanding dues. Manish Bhandari, managing director of the company, stated, "The government must find why there were just around 50 cylinders instead of 400 on that particular day when deaths took place. I suspect a big oxygen cylinder theft or racket, which they must find it out."[20]
The National Human Rights Council (NHRC) issued a notice to the state government, taking suo moto cognisance and seeking a report from the state government. It said that the incident indicates "gross callousness" on the part of the hospital and the state administration, and asked the government what steps were been taken to compensate the families.[21]
The Samajwadi Party accused the state government of encouraging corrupt practices at the hospital.[22]
References
- "Gorakhpur Deaths: Adityanath Government Ignored SOS on Oxygen Payments for Months". The Wire. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- "Sharp drop in BRD hospital deaths this year: Govt data". The Times of India. PTI. 3 September 2017.
- "36 children die in last 48 hours at Gorakhpur's BRD medical college". DNA. 29 August 2017.
- Singh, Manoj (1 December 2017). "Stifling the Truth : The government and media's cover-up after the Gorakhpur tragedy". The Caravan. Retrieved 7 December 2019.
- Prabhash K Dutta. "Gorakhpur has a history of children's deaths, 25,000 kids have lost lives to encephalitis". India Today.
- "Gorakhpur hospital deaths: Yogi Adityanath, J P Nadda visit BRD as death toll rises to 72". The Indian Express. 13 August 2017. Retrieved 13 August 2017.
- "Kafeel Khan, Prime Accused in Gorakhpur Tragedy, Asserts Innocence in Letter". The Wire. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- "Gorakhpur hospital tragedy: Three more children die, toll rises to 63 in five days". scroll.in. 12 August 2017. Retrieved 15 August 2017.
- Husain, Yusra (12 August 2017). "Gorakhpur hospital deaths: BRD Medical College principal suspended". The Times of India. Retrieved 13 August 2017.
- Dixit, Pawan. "Gorakhpur deaths: Doctor who was hailed as 'hero' removed from BRD hospital post". Hindustan Times. Retrieved 15 August 2017.
- "Gorakhpur probe report says children died due to oxygen crisis, blames principal and doctors". hindustantimes.com/. 17 August 2017. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- "Oxygen supply records were fudged: Gorakhpur DM's report ►". The Times of India. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- "Gorakhpur: Vacant posts, hygiene lacking at BRD hospital, notes Central team". The Indian Express. 19 August 2017. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- Singh, Manoj (1 June 2018). "The UP government's farcical investigation into the Gorakhpur tragedy". The Caravan. Retrieved 7 December 2019.
- Udayakumar, Ganesh Kumar Radha (12 August 2017). "PM Narendra Modi is constantly monitoring situation in Gorakhpur, his office says". India Today. Retrieved 13 August 2017.
- Sharma, Aman (13 August 2017). "Oxygen doesn't seem to be reason for Gorakhpur children dying: UP Health Minister SN Singh". Retrieved 13 August 2017.
- Basu, Snigdha (13 August 2017). "Facing Anger, Yogi Adityanath Visits Gorakhpur Hospital: 10 Points". NDTV. Retrieved 13 August 2017.
- "Congress Calls For Supreme Court Monitored Probe into Gorakhpur Deaths". NDTV. 13 August 2017. Retrieved 13 August 2017.
- "Amit Shah on Gorakhpur deaths: Tragedies have occurred under Congress rule too". The Indian Express. 14 August 2017. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- "Gorakhpur: Vendor says supply never stopped, thefts likely". The Times of India. Retrieved 15 August 2017.
- "Gorakhpur deaths: NHRC calls it gross callousness". Deccan Herald. 14 August 2017. Retrieved 15 August 2018.
- "Samajwadi Party accuses Uttar Pradesh govt of promoting corruption at Gorakhpur's BRD Medical College – Firstpost". firstpost.com. Retrieved 15 August 2018.