Emil Hácha

Emil Dominik Josef Hácha (12 July 1872 – 27 June 1945) was a Czech lawyer, the third President of Czechoslovakia from November 1938 to March 1939. In March 1939, after the breakup of Czechoslovakia, Hácha was the nominal state President of the newly proclaimed German Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia.

Emil Hácha
State President of the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia
In office 16 March 1939 – 9 May 1945
Prime Minister	Rudolf Beran (acting, 1939) Alois Eliáš (1939-1941) Jaroslav Krejčí (1941-1945) Richard Bienert (1945)
3rd President of Czechoslovakia
In office 30 November 1938 – 14 March 1939
Prime Minister	Jan Syrový (1938) Rudolf Beran (1938-39)
Preceded by	Edvard Beneš
Succeeded by	Edvard Beneš
Personal details
Born	12 July 1872 Trhové Sviny, Bohemia, Austria-Hungary
Died	27 June 1945 (aged 72) Prague, Czechoslovakia
Political party	National Partnership
Spouse(s)	Marie Háchová (1873–1938)
Profession	Lawyer
Signature

Early life

Emil Hácha was born on 12 July 1872 in the South Bohemian town of Trhové Sviny.[1]

Judicial career

He graduated from a secondary school in Budweis and then applied for the law faculty at the University of Prague. After finishing his studies in 1896 (JUDr.) he worked for the Country Committee of the Kingdom of Bohemia in Prague (a self-government body with quite limited power). Shortly after the outbreak of World War I, he became a judge at the Supreme Administrative Court in Vienna (the court was responsible for Cisleithania). He met Ferdinand Pantůček there.

After the Treaty of Versailles, Pantůček became President of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Republic of Czechoslovakia in Prague, and Hácha became a judge (1918) and Deputy President (1919) of the court.

After Pantůček's death in 1925 he was chosen by T. G. Masaryk as his successor, becoming first President of the Supreme Administration Court.[1]

He became one of the most notable lawyers in Czechoslovakia,[2] a specialist in English common law and international law. He was also a translator of English literature (most notably Three Men in a Boat by Jerome K. Jerome), collector of art and a poet. His book Omyly a přeludy (Errors and Delusions) was published in 1939 anonymously, then later under his own name in 2001.[3] He also became a member of the Legislative Council.

President of Czechoslovakia

Second Czechoslovak Republic

Hácha, Hitler and Göring meeting in Berlin, March 1939

Following the Munich Agreement, Hácha was nominated as successor to Edvard Beneš on 30 November 1938 as President of Czechoslovakia.[1] He was nominated because of his Catholicism, conservatism and lack of involvement in any of the governments that had led to the partition of the country.

The short era of his presidency before the German occupation is known as the Second Czechoslovak Republic and was marked by the shift from democracy to authoritarian state with the Enabling act giving previously unusual powers to the president and government and restricting the powers of the parliament.

After the secession of Slovakia and Ruthenia, British Ambassador to Czechoslovakia Basil Newton advised President Hácha to meet with Hitler.[4] When Hácha first arrived in Berlin, he first met with the German Foreign Minister, Joachim von Ribbentrop prior to meeting with Hitler. Von Ribbentrop testified at the Nuremberg trials that during this meeting Hácha had told him that "he wanted to place the fate of the Czech State in the Führer's hands."[5]

In the evening of 14 March 1939, Hitler summoned President Hácha to the Reich Chancellery in Berlin.[1] Hitler deliberately kept him waiting for hours, while Hitler watched a film.[6] Wilhelm Keitel in his memoirs recalled that when Hácha arrived Hitler said that "he was going to let the old gentleman rest and recover for two hours" which was incomprehensible to Keitel.[7] Finally, at 1:30 a.m., on 15 March 1939, Hitler saw the President. He told Hácha that as they were speaking, the German army was about to invade Czechoslovakia.[1]

Hitler then gave the Czech President two options: cooperate with Germany, in which case the "entry of German troops would take place in a tolerable manner" and "permit Czechoslovakia a generous life of her own, autonomy and a degree of national freedom..." or face a scenario in which "resistance would be broken by force of arms, using all means."[8] Minutes of the conversation noted that for Hácha this was the most difficult decision of his life, but believed that in only a few years this decision would be comprehensible and in 50 years would probably be regarded as a blessing.[9] According to Joachim Fest, Hácha suffered a heart attack induced by Göring's threat to bomb the capital and by four o'clock he contacted Prague, effectively "signing Czechoslovakia away" to Germany.[10] Göring acknowledged making the threat to the British ambassador to Germany, Neville Henderson, but said that the threat came as a warning because the Czech government, after already agreeing to German occupation, couldn't guarantee that the Czech army would not fire on the advancing Germans.[11] Göring however doesn't mention that Hácha had a heart attack because of his threat.

The French Ambassador Robert Coulondre reported that according to an unnamed, considered a reliable source by Coulondre, by half past four, Hácha was "in a state of total collapse, and kept going only by means of injections."[12] Coulondre described the scene at the Reich Chancellory:

"The German ministers [Göring and Ribbentrop] were pitiless. They literally hunted Dr. Hácha and M. Chvalkovsky round the table on which the documents were lying, thrusting them continually before them, pushing pens into their hands, incessantly repeating that if they continued in their refusal, half of Prague would lie in ruins from bombing within two hours, and that this would be only the beginning. Hundreds of bombers were waiting the order to take off, and they would receive that order at six in the morning if the signatures were not forthcoming".[13]

However, Hitler's interpreter Paul Schmidt, who was present during the meeting, in his memoirs denied such turbulent scenes ever taking place with the Czechoslovak President.[14] Historian Jean Ancel noted that Schmidt's memoirs are not a reliable source of information as he consistently downplayed and ignored the criminal policies of the Nazi regime as well his own role in them.[15]

Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia

After the occupation of the remnants of Czechoslovakia on 16 March,[16] Hácha retained his office as President, but was forced to swear an oath to Hitler, who appointed Konstantin von Neurath as Protector of Bohemia and Moravia.[17] During his time as President of the Protectorate, Hácha also signed into law legislation modeled after the Nazi Nuremberg Laws that discriminated against Czech Jews.[18] He dissolved the parliament, replacing it with the National Partnership.[19]

Hácha's situation changed on 29 September 1941 when Reinhard Heydrich was appointed Deputy Protector of Bohemia and Moravia, as Neurath had been considered not harsh enough by Hitler. Hácha lost all remaining influence over the matters in his country and became a puppet. Many of his colleagues and friends were arrested (including the Prime Minister Alois Eliáš) and shot or sent to concentration camps.

After the death of Heydrich, the new Deputy Protector was Kurt Daluege. Hitler had originally planned to execute 10,000 Czechs in reprisal for the murder of Heydrich and warned Hácha that if another such incident occurred, "we should have to consider deporting the whole Czech population".[20] This threat was made at Heydrich's funeral.[21]

On 9 May 1945, Prague was liberated by the Red Army during the Prague Offensive. Emil Hácha was arrested on 13 May and transferred immediately to Pankrác Prison. He died in prison on 27 June[1][22] under mysterious circumstances, with many historians entertaining the possibility of assassination, a suspicion shared by the Hácha family. After his death, he was buried at first in an unmarked grave at the Vinohrady Cemetery, but now there is a marker on his grave.[22]

Personal

In 1902, Hácha married Marie Háchová, née Klaus (born 17 April 1873 in Prague, died 6 February 1938 in Prague). They had a daughter, Milada. Marie died ten months before Hácha became president.

See also

• List of unsolved deaths

Citations

1. Snyder "Hácha, Emil" Encyclopedia of the Third Reich p. 134
2. Mazower Hitler's Empire p. 55
3. Emil Hácha, in Czech
4. Nicoll, Britain’s Blunder (German edition) p. 63.
5. Nuremberg Trial Proceedings Vol. 10 Friday, 29 March 1946 Avalon
6. Evans Third Reich in Power pp. 682–684
7. Keitel, Third Reich in Power p. 79
8. Fest Hitler pp. 570–571
9. The Road to War III: Appeasement to Occupation of Prague. 15 March 1939 Notes of Conversation between Adolf Hitler and Emil Hacha. Boston College
10. Fest Hitler pp. 570–571
11. IMT XXXI DOCUMENT 2861-PS, p. 246
12. Robert Coulondre to Georges Bonnet, Minister for Foreign Affairs. Berlin, March 17, 1939., available online here: http://avalon.law.yale.edu/wwii/ylbk077.asp
13. Shirer, William The Rise of and Fall of the Third Reich, New York: Simon and Schuster, 1960 pages 446-447
14. Schultze-Rhonhof, 1939 - the War that Had Many Fathers p. 231
15. Ancel, Jean The History of the Holocaust in Romania, Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2011 page 214.
16. Kershaw Hitler pp. 170–171
17. Evans Third Reich in Power pp. 685–686
18. "Nuremberg Laws Proclaimed in Czech Protectorate by President Hacha". Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 24 March 1942. Retrieved 29 March 2016.
19. Gruner, Wolf (2015). "Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia". In Gruner, Wolf; Osterloh, Jörg (eds.). The Greater German Reich and the Jews: Nazi Persecution Policies in the Annexed Territories 1935-1945. War and Genocide. Translated by Heise, Bernard. New York: Berghahn Books. pp. 105–106. ISBN 978-1-78238-444-1.
20. Evans Third Reich at War p. 277
21. Mazower Hitler's Empire p. 213
22. Emil Hacha, hrad.cz, retrieved 20 November 2013

References

• Evans, Richard J. (2009). The Third Reich at War. New York: Penguin Press. ISBN 978-1-59420-206-3.
• Evans, Richard J. (2005). The Third Reich in Power. New York: Penguin Press. ISBN 1-59420-074-2.
• Fest, Joachim (1974). Hitler. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
• Kershaw, Ian (2000). Hitler: 1936–1945 Nemesis. New York: W. W. Norton. ISBN 0-393-32252-1.
• Mazower, Mark (2008). Hitler's Empire: How the Nazis Ruled Europe. Penguin Press. ISBN 978-1-59420-188-2.
• Snyder, Louis L. (1976). "Hácha, Emil". Encyclopedia of the Third Reich. McGraw-Hill. p. 134. ISBN 0070595259.

External links

• (in English) Dramatic account by French diplomats of Emil Hácha's reluctance to sign over Bohemia and Moravia to Germany
• (in Czech) Hácha's report on the 15 March meeting in Berlin
• (in English) The complex legacy of the president many would prefer to forget
• Newspaper clippings about Emil Hácha in the 20th Century Press Archives of the ZBW