Retranslation

Retranslation refers to the action of "translating a work that has previously been translated into the same language" or to the text itself that was retranslated.[1] Retranslation of classic literature and religious texts is common. Retranslation may happen for many reasons, e.g., in order to update obsolete language, in order to improve the quality of translation, in order to account for a revised edition of the source text, or because a translator wishes to present a new interpretation or creative response to a text.[2] This is most common in poetry and drama.

The translation scholar Lawrence Venuti has argued that texts with very great cultural authority, including "the Bible, [...] the Homeric epics, Dante's Divine Comedy, Shakespeare's plays, or the Miguel de Cervantes novel Don Quixote, are likely to prompt retranslation because different readerships in the receiving culture may have different interpretations, and may want to apply their own values to the text."[3]

Retranslation is common in subtitling. It is less common in dubbing and the response from viewers is not always positive.[4]

Different ways of using the term

The term 'retranslation' has been used to mean various things, including indirect translation, also known as relay translation, where a text is translated into one language and then that translation is translated into a further language. In translation studies, the accepted meaning is now as a new translation into the same target language of a previously translated work.[5] The traditional conceptualization holds that the process is linear[6] or chronological, with retranslation always taking place after the first translation.[7] Modern usage, however, does not always imply this[7] and may be demonstrated in the following examples:

• Retranslations occurring simultaneously or near-simultaneously so that it is difficult to determine the first from succeeding translations.[8]
• Retranslations produced in the same language but different markets such as French and French Canadian.[8]
• Retranslations made on the assumption that previous translations are not acceptable.[6]

Retranslation hypothesis

In a 1990 issue of the translation journal Palimpsestes, Paul Bensimon and Antoine Berman posited what is known as the "retranslation hypothesis". They argued that the first translation of a text into a given language tends to adapt the text to the norms and conventions of the target language and culture, while later translations tend to stay closer to the original, because if a text is translated again it is because its status in the new culture has prompted a second (or further) translation.[9][10]

The hypothesis has been tested by a number of subsequent scholars who have suggested that it is too simplistic. In an article on retranslation in Finland, Paloposki and Koskinen argue that although many retranslations do conform to Berman and Bensimon's model, "there are no inherent qualities in the process of retranslating that would dictate a move from domesticating strategies towards more foreignising strategies."[11]

Well-known retranslations

The first translation by H.M. Parshley in 1953 of Simone de Beauvoir's 1949 book The Second Sex (Le Deuxième Sexe), has been much criticised.[12] A new translation by Constance Borde and Sheila Malovany-Chevalier appeared in 2009 and was felt by many critics to be a more accurate representation of de Beauvoir's text.[13] As some commentators have pointed out, however, when a translation has been enormously influential it can be hard to argue that it is somehow a failure.[14]

Many classic Russian novels have been translated a number of times; in recent years Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky have produced well-received retranslations of works including Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov and The Idiot, and Leo Tolstoy's War and Peace and Anna Karenina.[15] Translations of Russian novels are often compared to early influential, but widely criticised, versions by Constance Garnett.

A new translation of Grimm's Fairy Tales appeared in 2014, entitled The Original Folk and Fairy Tales of the Brothers Grimm and published by Princeton University Press. The editor and translator was Jack Zipes, who included all 156 stories from the first editions of 1812 and 1915, many of which were omitted from later editions and translations because of their disturbing subject matter.[16] The new translation revealed the extent to which previous translations had been censored, or based on censored source texts.[17]

Retranslations in other media

The 2008 Swedish film Let the Right One In (Swedish: Låt den rätte komma in) was released on DVD in the United States with subtitles different from those seen in movie theaters. This led to a number of complaints and the theatrical subtitles were restored to later issues of the DVD.[18][19]

Timur Bekmambetov's 2004 film Night Watch was shown in cinemas with specially designed subtitles which blended with the action.[20] When the film was released on DVD, some viewers were disappointed to find that these subtitles had been replaced with more conventionally formatted subtitles.[21]

The subtitler Lenny Borger has resubtitled a number of French classics for Rialto Pictures, including La grande illusion, Rififi and Children of Paradise. Speaking about Children of Paradise, Borger said that "it's like what they say about translations of great literature- every new generation should have a new translation."[22]

References

1. Şehnaz Tahir Gürçağlar, 'Retranslation' in Mona Baker & Gabriela Saldanha (eds.) Routledge Encyclopedia of Translation Studies (2nd ed.) p. 233
2. Isabelle Vanderschelden, 'Re-Translation' in Olive Classe (ed.) Routledge Encyclopedia of Literary Translation into English (2000, vol.2) p. 1155
3. Lawrence Venuti, 'Retranslations: The creation of value' in Bucknell Review 47(1) (2004), pp. 25-38
4. Campagna anti-ridoppiaggio
5. Kaisa Koskinen and Outi Paloposki, "Retranslation" in Luc van Doorslaer & Yves Gambier (eds.) Handbook of Translation Studies, vol.1. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 2010, pp. 294-298
6. Baker, Mona; Saldanha, Gabriela (2009). Routledge Encyclopedia of Translation Studies, Second Edition. Oxon, UK: Routledge. p. 235. ISBN 9780415369305.
7. Hansen, Gyde; Malmkjær, Kirsten; Gile, Daniel (2004). Claims, Changes and Challenges in Translation Studies: Selected Contributions from the EST Congress, Copenhagen 2001. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing. p. 37. ISBN 9027216568.
8. Gambier, Yves; Doorslaer, Luc van (2010). Handbook of Translation Studies, Volume 1. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing. p. 294. ISBN 9789027203311.
9. Şehnaz Tahir Gürçağlar, 'Retranslation' in Mona Baker & Gabriela Saldanha (eds.) Routledge Encyclopedia of Translation Studies (2nd ed.) p. 233
10. Outi Paloposki and Kaisa Koskinen, 'A thousand and one translations: Revisiting retranslation' in G. Hansen, K. Malmkjaer, D. Gile (eds.) Claims, Changes and Challenges in Translation Studies: Selected Contributions from the EST Congress, Copenhagen 2001. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 2004, pp. 27-38
11. Outi Paloposki and Kaisa Koskinen, 'A thousand and one translations: Revisiting retranslation' in Gyde Hansen, Kirsten Malmkjaer, Daniel Gile (eds.) Claims, Change and Challenges in Translation Studies: Selected Contributions from the EST Congress, Copenhagen 2001. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 2004, pp. 27-38
12. Moi, Toril, "While we wait: The English translation of The Second Sex" in Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society vol. 27, no. 4 (2002), pp. 1005–1035.
13. Smith, Joan, "The Second Sex", in The Independent (London).
14. Crowe, Catriona, "Second can be the best". The Irish Times
15. Abramovich, Alex. "Russian-to-English translators turned Oprah stars", Newsday article, July 31, 2004, reproduced in EIZIE. Retrieved 2011-02-27.
16. Princeton University Press website
17. Alison Flood, "Grimm brothers’ fairytales have blood and horror restored in new translation", The Guardian, 12 November 2014
18. Let The Wrong Subtitles In To LET THE RIGHT ONE IN?!
19. US Distributor Of 'Let The Right One In' Says They'll Fix Subtitles, But No Exchanges
20. The director Timur Bekmambetov turns film subtitling into an art
21. Michael Reuben, HTF Blu-ray Review: NIGHT WATCH / DAY WATCH
22. Lenny Borger, The Paris Interview

External links

• Isabelle Desmidt, 'Retranslation revisited'
• Lenny Borger, The Paris Interview