Roger Cotes

Roger Cotes FRS (10 July 1682 – 5 June 1716) was an English mathematician, known for working closely with Isaac Newton by proofreading the second edition of his famous book, the Principia, before publication. He also invented the quadrature formulas known as Newton–Cotes formulas, and made a geometric argument that can be interpreted as a logarithmic version of Euler's formula.[5] He was the first Plumian Professor at Cambridge University from 1707 until his death.

Roger Cotes
This bust was commissioned by Robert Smith and sculpted posthumously by Peter Scheemakers in 1758.
Born	10 July 1682 Burbage, Leicestershire, England
Died	5 June 1716 (aged 33) Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, England
Nationality	British
Alma mater	Trinity College, Cambridge
Known for	Logarithmic spiral Least squares Newton–Cotes formulas Euler's formula proof Concept of the radian
Scientific career
Fields	Mathematician
Institutions	Trinity College, Cambridge
Academic advisors	Isaac Newton Richard Bentley[1]
Notable students	Robert Smith[2] James Jurin[3] Stephen Gray
Influences	John Smith (his uncle)[4]

Early life

Cotes was born in Burbage, Leicestershire. His parents were Robert, the rector of Burbage, and his wife, Grace, née Farmer. Roger had an elder brother, Anthony (born 1681), and a younger sister, Susanna (born 1683), both of whom died young. At first Roger attended Leicester School, where his mathematical talent was recognised. His aunt Hannah had married Rev. John Smith, and Smith took on the role of tutor to encourage Roger's talent. The Smiths' son, Robert Smith, would become a close associate of Roger Cotes throughout his life. Cotes later studied at St Paul's School in London and entered Trinity College, Cambridge, in 1699.[6] He graduated BA in 1702 and MA in 1706.[2]

Astronomy

Roger Cotes's contributions to modern computational methods lie heavily in the fields of astronomy and mathematics. Cotes began his educational career with a focus on astronomy. He became a fellow of Trinity College in 1707, and at age 26 he became the first Plumian Professor of Astronomy and Experimental Philosophy. On his appointment to professor, he opened a subscription list in an effort to provide an observatory for Trinity. Unfortunately, the observatory still was unfinished when Cotes died, and was demolished in 1797.[2]

In correspondence with Isaac Newton, Cotes designed a heliostat telescope with a mirror revolving by clockwork.[7][8] He recomputed the solar and planetary tables of Giovanni Domenico Cassini and John Flamsteed, and he intended to create tables of the moon's motion, based on Newtonian principles. Finally, in 1707 he formed a school of physical sciences at Trinity in partnership with William Whiston.[2]

The Principia

From 1709 to 1713, Cotes became heavily involved with the second edition of Newton's Principia, a book that explained Newton's theory of universal gravitation. The first edition of Principia had only a few copies printed and was in need of revision to include Newton's works and principles of lunar and planetary theory.[2] Newton at first had a casual approach to the revision, since he had all but given up scientific work. However, through the vigorous passion displayed by Cotes, Newton's scientific hunger was once again reignited. The two spent nearly three and half years collaborating on the work, in which they fully deduce, from Newton's laws of motion, the theory of the moon, the equinoxes, and the orbits of comets. Only 750 copies of the second edition were printed.[2] However, a pirate copy from Amsterdam met all other demand. As reward to Cotes, he was given a share of the profits and 12 copies of his own. Cotes's original contribution to the work was a preface which supported the scientific superiority of Newton's principles over the then popular vortex theory of gravity advocated by René Descartes. Cotes concluded that the Newton's law of gravitation was confirmed by observation of celestial phenomena that were inconsistent with the vortex phenomena that Cartesian critics alleged.[2]

Mathematics

Cotes's major original work was in mathematics, especially in the fields of integral calculus, logarithms, and numerical analysis. He published only one scientific paper in his lifetime, titled Logometria, in which he successfully constructs the logarithmic spiral.[9][10] After his death, many of Cotes's mathematical papers were hastily edited by his cousin Robert Smith and published in a book, Harmonia mensurarum.[2][11] Cotes's additional works were later published in Thomas Simpson's The Doctrine and Application of Fluxions.[9] Although Cotes's style was somewhat obscure, his systematic approach to integration and mathematical theory was highly regarded by his peers. Cotes discovered an important theorem on the n-th roots of unity,[12] foresaw the method of least squares,[13] and discovered a method for integrating rational fractions with binomial denominators.[9][14] He was also praised for his efforts in numerical methods, especially in interpolation methods and his table construction techniques.[9] He was regarded as one of the few British mathematicians capable of following the powerful work of Sir Isaac Newton.

Death and assessment

Cotes died from a violent fever in Cambridge in 1716 at the early age of 33. Isaac Newton remarked, "If he had lived we would have known something."[2]

See also

• Newton–Cotes formulas
• Lituus (mathematics)
• Cotes's spiral

References

1. Gowing 2002, p. 5.
2. Meli (2004)
3. Rusnock (2004) "Jurin, James (bap. 1684, d. 1750)", Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, accessed 6 September 2007 (subscription or UK public library membership required)
4. Gowing 2002, p. 6.
5. Cotes wrote: "Nam si quadrantis circuli quilibet arcus, radio CE descriptus, sinun habeat CX sinumque complementi ad quadrantem XE ; sumendo radium CE pro Modulo, arcus erit rationis inter ${\displaystyle EX+XC{\sqrt {-1}}}$& CE mensura ducta in ${\displaystyle {\sqrt {-1}}}$." (Thus if any arc of a quadrant of a circle, described by the radius CE, has sinus CX and sinus of the complement to the quadrant XE ; taking the radius CE as modulus, the arc will be the measure of the ratio between ${\displaystyle EX+XC{\sqrt {-1}}}$ & CE multiplied by ${\displaystyle {\sqrt {-1}}}$.) That is, consider a circle having center E (at the origin of the (x,y) plane) and radius CE. Consider an angle θ with its vertex at E having the positive x-axis as one side and a radius CE as the other side. The perpendicular from the point C on the circle to the x-axis is the "sinus" CX ; the line between the circle's center E and the point X at the foot of the perpendicular is XE, which is the "sinus of the complement to the quadrant" or "cosinus". The ratio between ${\displaystyle EX+XC{\sqrt {-1}}}$ and CE is thus ${\displaystyle \cos \theta +{\sqrt {-1}}\sin \theta \ }$. In Cotes' terminology, the "measure" of a quantity is its natural logarithm, and the "modulus" is a conversion factor that transforms a measure of angle into circular arc length (here, the modulus is the radius (CE) of the circle). According to Cotes, the product of the modulus and the measure (logarithm) of the ratio, when multiplied by ${\displaystyle {\sqrt {-1}}}$, equals the length of the circular arc subtended by θ, which for any angle measured in radians is CE • θ. Thus, ${\displaystyle {\sqrt {-1}}CE\ln {\left(\cos \theta +{\sqrt {-1}}\sin \theta \right)\ }=(CE)\theta }$. This equation has the wrong sign: the factor of ${\displaystyle {\sqrt {-1}}}$ should be on the right side of the equation, not the left side. If this change is made, then, after dividing both sides by CE and exponentiating both sides, the result is: ${\displaystyle \cos \theta +{\sqrt {-1}}\sin \theta =e^{{\sqrt {-1}}\theta }}$, which is Euler's formula.
   See:
   • Roger Cotes (1714) "Logometria," Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 29 (338) : 5-45 ; see especially page 32. Available on-line at: Hathi Trust
   • Roger Cotes with Robert Smith, ed., Harmonia mensurarum … (Cambridge, England: 1722), chapter: "Logometria", p. 28.
6. "Cotes, Roger (CTS699R)". A Cambridge Alumni Database. University of Cambridge.
7. Edleston, J., ed. (1850) Correspondence of Sir Isaac Newton and Professor Cotes, … (London, England: John W. Parker), "Letter XCVIII. Cotes to John Smith." (1708 February 10), pp. 197–200.
8. Kaw, Autar (1 January 2003). "cotes - A Historical Anecdote". mathforcollege.com. Retrieved 12 December 2017.
9. O'Connor & Robertson (2005)
10. In Logometria, Cotes evaluated e, the base of natural logarithms, to 12 decimal places. See: Roger Cotes (1714) "Logometria," Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 29 (338) : 5-45; see especially the bottom of page 10. From page 10: "Porro eadem ratio est inter 2,718281828459 &c et 1, … " (Furthermore, the same ratio is between 2.718281828459… and 1, … )
11. Harmonia mensurarum contains a chapter of comments on Cotes' work by Robert Smith. On page 95, Smith gives the value of 1 radian for the first time. See: Roger Cotes with Robert Smith, ed., Harmonia mensurarum … (Cambridge, England: 1722), chapter: Editoris notæ ad Harmoniam mensurarum, top of page 95. From page 95: After stating that 180° corresponds to a length of π (3.14159…) along a unit circle (i.e., π radians), Smith writes: "Unde Modulus Canonis Trigonometrici prodibit 57.2957795130 &c. " (Whence the conversion factor of trigonometric measure, 57.2957795130… [degrees per radian], will appear.)
12. Roger Cotes with Robert Smith, ed., Harmonia mensurarum … (Cambridge, England: 1722), chapter: "Theoremata tum logometrica tum triogonometrica datarum fluxionum fluentes exhibentia, per methodum mensurarum ulterius extensam" (Theorems, some logorithmic, some trigonometric, which yield the fluents of given fluxions by the method of measures further developed), pages 113-114.
13. Roger Cotes with Robert Smith, ed., Harmonia mensurarum … (Cambridge, England: 1722), chapter: "Aestimatio errorum in mixta mathesis per variationes partium trianguli plani et sphaerici" Harmonia mensurarum ... , pages 1-22, see especially page 22. From page 22: "Sit p locus Objecti alicujus ex Observatione prima definitus, … ejus loco tutissime haberi potest." (Let p be the location of some object defined by observation, q, r, s, the locations of the same object from subsequent observations. Let there also be weights P, Q, R, S reciprocally proportional to the displacements that may arise from the errors in the single observations, and that are given from the given limits of error; and the weights P, Q, R, S are conceived as being placed at p, q, r, s, and their center of gravity Z is found: I say the point Z is the most probable location of the object, and may be most safely had for its true place. [Ronald Gowing, 1983, p. 107])
14. Cotes presented his method in a letter to William Jones, dated May 5, 1716. An excerpt from the letter which discusses the method was published in: [Anon.] (1722), Book review: "An account of a book, intitled, Harmonia Mensurarum, … ," Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 32 : 139-150 ; see pages 146-148.

Sources

• [Anon.] "Cotes, Roger" . Encyclopædia Britannica. 7 (11th ed.). 1911.
• Cohen, I. B. (1971). Introduction to Newton's "Principia". Harvard: Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-46193-2.
• Edleston, J. (ed.) (1850). Correspondence of Sir Isaac Newton and Professor Cotes.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link) via Internet Archive
• Gowing, R. (2002). Roger Cotes: Natural Philosopher. London: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-52649-3.
• Koyré, A. (1965). Newtonian Studies. London: Chapman & Hall. pp. 273–82. ISBN 0-412-42300-6.
• O'Connor, John J.; Robertson, Edmund F., "Roger Cotes", MacTutor History of Mathematics archive, University of St Andrews. (2005)
• Meli, D. B. (2004) "Cotes, Roger (1682–1716)", Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, accessed 7 September 2007 (subscription or UK public library membership required)
• Price, D. J. (1952). "The early observatory instruments of Trinity College, Cambridge". Annals of Science. 8: 1–12. doi:10.1080/00033795200200012.
• Turnbull, H. W.; et al. (1975–1976). The Correspondence of Isaac Newton (7 vols ed.). London: Cambridge University Press. vols.5–6.
• Whitman, A. et al. (eds) (1972). Isaac Newton's Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica: The Third Edition (1726) with Variant Readings. London: Cambridge University Press. pp. 817–26. ISBN 0-521-07960-8.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)

External links

• "Harmonia Mensurarum". MathPages. Retrieved 7 September 2007.- A more complete account of Cotes's involvement with Principia, followed by an even more thorough discussion of his mathematical work.
• Roger Cotes at the Mathematics Genealogy Project