Bark (sound)

A bark is a sound most commonly produced by dogs. Other animals that make this noise include wolves,[1] coyotes, seals and quolls. Woof is the most common onomatopoeia in the English language for this sound, especially for large dogs. "Bark" is also a verb that describes the sharp explosive cry of certain animals.

In dogs

Dog barking is distinct from wolf barking. Wolf barks represent only 2.4% of all wolf vocalizations[2] and are described as "rare" occurrences.[3] According to Schassburger, wolves bark only in warning, defense, and protest. In contrast, dogs bark in a wide variety of social situations, with acoustic communication in dogs being described as hypertrophic.[4] Additionally, while wolf barks tend to be brief and isolated, adult dogs bark in long, rhythmic stanzas. Dogs have been known to bark for hours on end.[5]

While a distinct reason for the difference is unknown, a strong hypothesis is that the vocal communication of dogs developed due to their domestication.[5] As evidenced by the farm-fox experiment, the process of domestication alters a breed in more ways than just tameness.[6] Domesticated breeds show vast physical differences from their wild counterparts, notably an evolution that suggests neoteny, or the retention of juvenile characteristics in adults.[7] Adult dogs have, for example, large heads, floppy ears, and shortened snouts – all characteristics seen in wolf puppies.[8] The behavior, too, of adult dogs shows puppy-like characteristics: dogs are submissive, they whine, and they frequently bark. The experiment illustrates how selecting for one trait (in this case, tameness) can create profound by-products, both physical and behavioral.

The frequency of barking in dogs in relation to wolves could also be the product of the very different social environment of dogs. Dogs live in extraordinarily close range with humans, in many societies kept solely as companion animals. From a very young age, humans tend to be one of a dog's primary social contacts. This captive environment presents very different stimuli than would be found by wolves in the wild. While wolves have vast territories, dogs do not. The boundaries of a captive dog's territory will be visited frequently by intruders, thus triggering the bark response as a warning. Additionally, dogs densely populate urban areas, allowing more opportunity to meet new dogs and be social. For example, it is possible that kenneled dogs may have increased barking due to a desire to facilitate social behavior. Dogs' close relationship with humans also renders dogs reliant on humans, even for basic needs. Barking is a way to attract attention, and the behavior is continued by the positive response exhibited by the owners (e.g., if a dog barks to get food and the owner feeds it, the dog is being conditioned to continue said behavior).[9]

Types

Barking in domestic dogs is a controversial topic. While barking is suggested to be "non-communicative,"[10] data suggests that it may well be a means of expression that became increasingly sophisticated during domestication. Due to the lack of consensus over whether or not dogs actually communicate using their barks, not much work has been done on categorizing the different types of barking in dogs. That which has been done has been criticized by Feddersen-Petersen as "lack[ing] objectivity." Using sonographic methods, Feddersen-Petersen identified several distinct types of barks, then analyzed them for meanings, functions, and emotions. He separated dog barks into subgroups based on said sonographic data:

Bark	Characteristics	Behavior
Infantile bark (pup yelp)	Harmonic	Emitted spontaneously in protest or as a distress call
Harmonic play bark	Mixed sounds involving "concurrent superimposition" of growls, noisy bark	After barking, play behavior was often observed.
"Christmas tree" bark	Sonogram displayed "Christmas tree" effect. There is a "sequential loss of overtones."	Seen in German Shepherds and Alaskan Malamutes.
Noisy overlappings	Short, overlapping sounds	Seen in poodles.
Pure harmonic sound		Often accompanied with play behavior.
Specific vibrato-growl
Noisy bark		Agonistic contexts only. Seen in Alaskan Malamutes.
Play-solicited barks	Often combined with growls, other bark subunits.	Matched with play behavior
Noisy play bark	Harsh, short sound. Low-pitched, with an extremely short, sharp rise.	Associated with more harsh play-fighting seen often in American Staffordshire Terriers and Bull Terriers. "Often show[ed] changeovers to aggressive interactions."
Threat bark	Short, low-pitched sound.
Warning bark	Short, low-pitched sound.

Not all breeds demonstrated every subgroup of barking. Instead, significant variance in vocalization was found between different breeds. Poodles showed the least of all barking subunits. Additionally, barking in wolves was observed as notably less diverse. For example, wolf barks are rarely harmonic, tending instead to be noisy.[11]

There is some evidence that humans can determine the suspected emotions of dogs while listening to barks emitted during specific situations. Humans scored the emotions of dogs performing these barks very similarly and in ways that made sense according to the situation at hand. In one example, when subjects were played a recording of a dog tied alone to a tree, a situation in which one could reasonably infer that the dog would be distressed, the human listeners tended to rank the bark as having a high level of despair. It has been suggested that this may be evidence for the idea that dog barks have evolved to be a form of communication with humans specifically, since humans can so readily determine a dog's needs by simply listening to their vocalizations.[12] Further studies have found that the acoustic structure of a bark "[varies] considerably with context."[13] These studies suggest that barks are more than just random sounds, and indeed hold some sort of communicative purpose.

As nuisance

Bark control

Signalling to a dog with the palm of the hand is prescribed as a way to address a dog that is alert barking

Splitting is prescribed as a way to address a dog that is alert barking

Nuisance-barking dogs sound off for no particular reason. "Many dogs bark when they hear other dogs barking," says Katherine A. Houpt, V.M.D., PhD, director of the Cornell Animal Behavior Clinic. Nuisance, inappropriate, or excessive barking comprises between 13 and 35 percent of behavior-problem complaints by dog owners, Houpt noted. The electric collars deliver an irritating shock of adjustable intensity when a vibration sensor in the collar detects barking. The citronella collar releases a spray of citronella when a microphone in the collar senses barking. For the eight dogs that wore both types of collars (one shepherd mix did not complete the study), all owners found the citronella collar to be effective in reducing or stopping nuisance barking and most preferred the fragrance spray. Four out of eight owners said electric shocks had no effect on their dogs—they kept on barking. The citronella collars had problems, Juarbe-D'az noted. One dog owner complained that citronella oil stained the upholstery when the dog, fond of lying about on upholstery, barked. "One owner thought the scent was preferable to her dog's body odor."

Dog barking can be a nuisance to neighbours, and is a common problem that dog owners or their neighbours may face. Many dogs can bark at 100 dBA. Even at 17.5 yards away and with the dog outside a closed window, the noise level of a barking dog can be well over the level that causes psychological distress.[14] Different kinds of barking often require different kinds of approach to reduction.[15]

Common approaches are as follows:

1. Attempting to understand, and if possible eliminate, the causes of barking.
2. Using positive training methods to correct the behaviour. Dogs may bark from anxiety or stress, so punishment can often cause problems by reinforcing a cycle of bad behaviour. Positive approaches can include:
   • Repeated exposure to stimuli whilst calming the dog and persuading it to remain quiet.
   • Distraction as the stimulus happens, through treats, praise, or similar.
   • Reshaping via clicker training (a form of operant conditioning) or other means to obtain barking behaviour on command, and then shaping the control to gain command over silence.
3. In her book Barking: The Sound of a Language,[16] Turid Rugaas explains that barking is a way a dog communicates. She suggests signalling back to show the dog that the dog's attempts to communicate have been acknowledge and to calm a dog down. She suggests the use of a hand signal and a Calming Signal called Splitting.
4. Seeking professional advice from local organizations, dog trainers, or veterinarians.
5. Use of a mechanical device such as a bark collar. There are several types, all of which use a collar device that produces a response to barking that the dog notices:
   • Citrus spray ("citronella") - dogs as a rule do not like citrus. At the least, it is very noticeable and disrupts the pattern through surprise. These collars spray citrus around the dog's muzzle when it barks. (Sometimes these devices make a "hissing" noise before spraying, as an additional deterrent – see "Combination and escalation devices" below)
   • Sonic/ultrasonic (including vibration) - these collars produce a tone which humans may or may not be able to hear, in response to barking. Over time, the sound becomes annoying or distracting enough to deter barking.
   • Electrical - these collars produce a mild stinging or tingling sensation in response to a bark. It is important that such devices have a failsafe mechanism and shut off after a certain time, to prevent ongoing operation.
   • Combination and escalation devices - many sound and/or electrical collars have combination or escalation systems. A combination system is one that (for example) uses both sound and spray together. An escalation device is one that uses quiet sounds, or low levels of output, rising gradually until barking ceases. Escalation devices are effective since they "reward" the dog for stopping sooner by not having "all-or-nothing" action, so the dog can learn to react by stopping before much happens.

Note:

• Various bark collars have been both praised and criticised; some are considered inhumane by various people and groups. Electrical devices especially come under criticism by people who consider them torturous and akin to electrocution. However most Societies for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals agree that in a last resort even an electric collar is better than euthanasia if it comes to an ultimatum, for a stubborn dog that will not stop any other way. It is generally agreed that understanding the communication and retraining by reward is the most effective and most humane way.

Surgical debarking

The controversial surgical procedure known as 'debarking' is a veterinary procedure for modifying the voice box so that a barking dog will make a significantly reduced noise. It is considered a last resort by some owners, on the basis that it is better than euthanasia, seizure, or legal problems if the matter has proven incapable of being reliably corrected any other way.

Debarking is illegal in many European states and opposed by animal welfare organizations.

Representation

Woof is the conventional representation in the English language of the barking of a dog. As with other examples of onomatopoeia or imitative sounds, other cultures "hear" the dog's barks differently and represent them in their own ways. Some of the equivalents of "woof" in other languages are as follows:

• English – woof woof; ruff ruff; arf arf (large dogs and also the sound of sea lions); yap yap; yip yip (small dogs), bow wow, bork bork
• Afrikaans – blaf; woef woef; kef (small dogs)
• Albanian – ham ham
• Arabic – hau hau; how how (هو, هو)
• Armenian – haf haf (հաֆ-հաֆ)
• Azeri – hum hum
• Basque – au au; txau txau (small dogs); zaunk zaunk (large dogs); jau jau (old dogs)
• Balinese – kong, kong
• Belgian (Flemish) – woef, woef; blaf, blaf; waf, waf (large dogs) Keff, keff; Wuff, Wuff (small dogs)
• Bengali – gheu, gheu; bhou, bhou
• Bulgarian – bau-bau (бау-бау); jaff, jaff (джаф-джаф)
• Burmese – woke, woke
• Catalan – bau-bau; bub-bub
• Chinese
  • Mandarin – wāngwāng (汪汪)
  • Cantonese – wou1 wou1 (㕵㕵)
• Cebuano- arf arf; aw aw
• Croatian – vau, vau
• Czech – haf, haf; štěk (the bark itself)
• Danish – vov vov; vuf vuf; bjæf bjæf
• Dutch – blaf, blaf; kef, kef; waf, waf; woef, woef
• Esperanto – boj, boj
• Estonian – auh, auh
• Finnish – hau hau; vuh, vuh; rauf, rauf
• Filipino – Aw Aw, Aw
• French – ouah, ouah; ouaf, ouaf; vaf, vaf; wouf, wouf; wouaf, wouaf; jappe jappe
• German – wau wau; wuff, wuff;
• Greek – gav, gav (γαβ, γαβ); vav, vav (βαβ, βαβ)
• Hebrew – hav, hav; hau, hau
• Hindi – bho.n, bho.n (भों भों)
• Hungarian – vau, vau
• Icelandic – voff, voff
• Indonesian – guk, guk
• Irish – amh, amh
• Italian – bau bau
• Japanese – wan-wan (ワンワン); kyan-kyan (キャンキャン)[17]
• Korean – meong-meong (멍멍, pronounced [mʌŋmʌŋ]), wal-wal (왈왈)
• Latvian – vau, vau
• Lithuanian – au, au
• Yugoslav Macedonian – av, av
• Malay – gonggong ("menggonggong" means barking)
• Marathi – bhu, bhu (भू भू)
• Norwegian: voff, voff or boff
• Persian – haap, haap (هاپ، هاپ)
• Polish – hau, hał
• Portuguese – au-au; ão-ão; béu-béu (toddler language); cain-cain (whining)
• Punjabi - bau-bau; ਬੌਉਂ-ਬੌਉਂ
• Romanian – ham-ham; hau, hau
• Russian – гав-гав (gav-gav); тяв-тяв (tyav-tyav (small dogs)); ав-ав (av-av (toddler language)); rarely ряв-ряв (ryaf-ryaf (angry dogs and bears))
• Serbian – av-av
• Sinhala: බුඃ බුඃ (buh buh)
• Slovak – haf, haf; hau, hau
• Slovene – hov, hov
• Spanish – guau-guau; gua-gua; jau-jau; bau-bau
• Swedish – voff; vov vov; bjäbb bjäbb
• Tagalog – aw aw; baw, baw
• Tamazight – hav hav; haw haw
• Tamil – வள் வள் - vaL vaL; லொள் லொள் – loL loL; வெள் வெள் – veL veL
• Thai – โฮ่ง โฮ่ง (pronounced [hôŋhôŋ]); บ๊อก บ๊อก (pronounced [bɔ́kbɔ́k])
• Turkish – hav, hav
• Ukrainian – гав-гав (hav-hav); дзяв-дзяв (dzyau-dzyau)
• Urdu – bow bow
• Vietnamese – gâu gâu; ẳng ẳng
• Welsh – wff, wff

Breeds

The Huntaway is a working dog that has been selectively bred to drive stock (usually sheep) by using its voice. It was bred in New Zealand, and is still bred based on ability rather than appearance or lineage.

Naturally "barkless" dog breeds

Compared to most domestic dogs, the bark of a dingo is short and monosyllabic. During observations, the barking of Australian dingoes was shown to have a relatively small variability; sub-groups of bark types, common among domestic dogs, could not be found. Furthermore, only 5% of the observed vocalizations were made up of barking. Australian dingoes bark only in swooshing noises or in a mixture atonal/tonal. Also, barking is almost exclusively used for giving warnings. Warn-barking in a homotypical sequence and a kind of "warn-howling" in a heterotypical sequence has also been observed. The bark-howling starts with several barks and then fades into a rising and ebbing howl and is probably, similarly to coughing, used to warn the puppies and members of the pack. Additionally, dingoes emit a sort of "wailing" sound, which they mostly use when approaching a water hole, probably to warn already present dingoes.[18] According to the present state of knowledge, it is not possible to get Australian dingoes to bark more frequently by making them associate with other domestic dogs. However, Alfred Brehm reported a dingo that completely learned the more "typical" form of barking and knew how to use it, while its brother did not.[19] Whether dingoes bark or bark-howl less frequently in general is not sure.[20]

The now extinct Hare Indian dog of northern Canada was not known to bark in its native homeland, though puppies born in Europe learned how to imitate the barking of other dogs.[21] When hurt or afraid, it howled like a wolf, and when curious, it made a sound described as a growl building up to a howl.[22]

The Basenji of central Africa produces an unusual yodel-like sound, due to its unusually shaped larynx.[23] This trait also gives the Basenji the nickname "Barkless Dog."[24]

Barking in other animals

Many animals communicate via various vocalizations. While there is not a precise, consistent and functional acoustic definition for barking, researchers may classify barks according to several criteria.[25] University of Massachusetts Amherst researchers identified that volume, pitch, tonality, noise, abrupt onset and pulse duration are amongst the criteria that can be used to define a bark.[26]

Besides dogs and wolves, other canines like coyotes and jackals can bark.[26] Their barks are quite similar to those of wolves and dogs. The bark of a dingo is short and monosyllabic.[27]

The warning bark of a fox is higher and more drawn out than barks of other canids.

There are non-canine species with vocalizations that are sometimes described as barking. Because the alarm call of the muntjac resembles a dog's bark, they are sometimes known as "barking deer". Eared seals are also known to bark. Prairie dogs employ a complex form of communication that involves barks and rhythmic chirps.[28] A wide variety of bird species produce vocalizations that include the canonical features of barking, especially when avoiding predators.[26] Some primate species, notably gorillas, can and do vocalize in short barks.

See also

• Animal communication
• Debarking
• Dog communication
• Dog training
• Growling

References

1. L. David Mech; Luigi Boitani (1 October 2010). Wolves: Behavior, Ecology, and Conservation. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 978-0-226-51698-1.
2. Schassburger, R.M. (1987). "Wolf vocalization: An integrated model of structure, motivation, and ontogeny". In H. Frank (ed.). Man and Wolf. Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Dr. W. Junk.
3. {{cite thesis|last=Coscia|first=E.M.|year=1995|title=Ontogeny of timber wolf vocalizations: Acoustic properties and behavioral contexts|type=PhD Dissertation|publisher=Dalhousie University|location=Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada|hdl=10000000334526j }
4. Fedderson-Peterson, D.U. (2000). "Vocalization of European wolves (Canus lupus lupus L.) and various dog breeds (Canus lupus f., fam.)". Arch. Tierz. Kiel, Germany: Institut für Haustierkunde, Christian-Albrechts-University. 4: 387–397.
5. Coppinger, R.; M. Feinstein (1991). "'Hark! Hark! The dogs do bark...' and bark and hark". Smithsonian. 21: 119–128.
6. Belyaev, D.K.; I.Z. Plyusnina; L.N. Trut (1984). "Domestication in the silver fox (Vulpus fulvus desm.) – changes in physiological boundaries of the sensitive period of primary socialization". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 13 (4): 359–370. doi:10.1016/0168-1591(85)90015-2.
7. Fox, M.W. (1986). Saunders, W.B. (ed.). "The influence of domestication upon behavior of animals". Abnormal Behaviour in Animals. Philadelphia: 179–187.
8. Dechambre, E. (1949). "La theorie de la foetalisation et la formation des races de chiens et de porcs". Mammalia (in French). 13: 129–137. doi:10.1515/mamm.1949.13.3.129.
9. Fox, M.W. (1971). "Behavior of wolves and related canids". Malabar, FL. Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
10. Coppinger, R; M. Feinstein. "'Hark! Hark! The dogs do bark...' and bark and bark". Smithsonian (21): 119–128.
11. Feddersen-Petersen, D.U. (2000). "Vocalization of European wolves (Canus lupus lupus L.) and various dog breeds (Canus lupus f., fam.)". Arch. Tierz. Kiel, Germany: Institut für Haustierkunde, Christian-Albrechts-University. 4: 387–397.
12. Pongrácz, P; Molnár, C.; Miklósi, Á.; Csányi, V. (2005). "Human Listeners Are Able to Classify Dog (Canis familiaris) Barks Recorded in Different Situations". Journal of Comparative Psychology. 2. 119: 136–144. doi:10.1037/0735-7036.119.2.136.
13. Yin, S (2002). "A New Perspective on Barking in Dogs (Canis familiaris)". Journal of Comparative Psychology. 2. 116: 189–193. doi:10.1037/0735-7036.116.2.189.
14. Richard Murray and Helen Penridge. Dogs in the Urban Environment. Chiron Media 1992, ISBN 0-646-07157-2, pp. 21–22.
15. Mordecai Siegal and Mathew Margolis. When Good Dogs Do Bad Things: Proven solutions to 30 common problems. Little, Brown and Co. 1986, ISBN 0-316-79012-5, pp. 33–44.
16. Rugaas, Turid (2008). Barking : the sound of a language. Wenatchee, Wash.: Dogwise Pub. ISBN 1929242514.
17. Rikaichan Japanese-English dictionary extension, version 2.01
18. Laurie Corbett (2004). "Dingo" (PDF). Canids: Foxes, Wolves, Jackals and Dogs. International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources. Retrieved 8 April 2009.
19. Brehms Tierleben (in German). Leipzig, Wien: Bibliographisches Institut. 1900. pp. 82–85.
20. Feddersen-Petersen, Dorit Urd (2008). Ausdrucksverhalten beim Hund (in German). Stuttgart: Franckh-Kosmos Verlags-GmbH & Co. KG. ISBN 978-3-440-09863-9.
21. The Gardens and Menagerie of the Zoological Society, Published, with the Sanction of the Council, Under the Superintendence of the Secretary and Vice-secretary of the Society, by Edward Turner Bennett, Zoological Society of London, William Harvey, Illustrated by John Jackson, William Harvey, G. B., S. S., Thomas Williams, Robert Edward Branston, George Thomas Wright. Published by Printed by C. Whittingham, 1830.
22. Fauna Boreali-americana, Or, The Zoology of the Northern Parts of British America: Containing Descriptions of the Objects of Natural History Collected on the Late Northern Land Expeditions, Under Command of Captain Sir John Franklin, R.N. By John Richardson, William Swainson, William Kirby, published by J. Murray, 1829.
23. Adapted from the book "Why Pandas Do Handstands," 2006, by Augustus Brown.
24. Tudor-Williams, Veronica (May 1988). "1945 Letter from Africa". The Basenji. BCOA African Stock Project. Retrieved 21 May 2019.
25. Not Only Dogs, But Deer, Monkeys And Birds Bark To Deal With Conflict. Science Daily. 15 July 2009.
26. Lord, Kathryn., Feinstein, Mark., Coppinger, Raymond. Barking and mobbing. Archived 29 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine Behavioural Processes. 2009.
27. Free Ranging Dogs - Stray, Feral or Wild?. Guillaume de Lavigne. Retrieved 11 March 2020.
28. Walker, Matt. Burrowing US prairie dogs use complex language. BBC Earth News. 2 February 2010.

External links

• "Article from ASPCA's Virtual Pet Behaviorist on working with barking problems"