Proposals for new tram lines in Edinburgh

Various studies, from 1989 onwards, considered the reintroduction of trams to Edinburgh.[1] In 2001, a proposal for a new Edinburgh Trams network envisaged three routes across the city, Lines 1, 2 and 3. Line 1 was a circular route running around the northern suburbs, with the other two forming radial lines running out to Newbridge in the west and to Newcraighall in the south respectively.[2] All lines would run through the city centre.

Line 3 was later shelved due to lack of Scottish Parliament approval. Lines 1 and 2 were combined and split into three phases, with Phase 1 being further divided into Phase 1a and 1b. Phases 1b, 2 and 3 were not funded, and as of 2013 only a truncated section of the planned Phase 1a line (running from the airport to the city centre) has been constructed.

Line 1 (North Edinburgh)

Diagram of Line 1 proposed in 2001

The planned route of the tram line along the waterfront at Granton

Line 1 was planned to be a 15.25 kilometres (9.48 mi) circular route with 22 stops running around the northern suburbs, following a route from the City Centre, St Andrew Square, York Place, Picardy Place, down Leith Walk to Leith and Newhaven. The line would then run along the waterfront to Granton, where it would then loop back, taking over the disused Caledonian Railway route between via Crewe Toll to Wester Coates and Haymarket. Upon reaching Haymarket, trams will return to on-street running mode and head back along Princes Street.

Line 1 comprised 2.3 kilometres (1.4 mi) of on-street track integrated with other traffic, 2.7 kilometres (1.7 mi) of segregated track running along existing roads, and 10.5 kilometres (6.5 mi) separate tramway. The on-street sections of track would be in the centre of the road in some locations and at the kerbside in others. On the disused line to Granton, the tram line would be integrated with cycle and pedestrian pathways along the Roseburn wildlife corridor.[3]

In the initial Phase 1a of the project, only the Newhaven-Leith Walk-Princes Street section of this route was included, with trams then continuing west to the airport (Line 2 route). Further construction of the Line 1 loop (Phase 1b of the project) was cancelled in 2009 due to financial constraints, postponing construction of the Haymarket-Granton section of this line indefinitely.[4] Phase 2, which would complete the loop with a line from Granton Square to Newhaven, also remains unfunded.

Name	Phase	Transport Interchange	Serves
Haymarket	Phase 1a	Haymarket railway station Lothian Buses Line 2 (West Edinburgh)	Edinburgh International Conference Centre St Mary's Music School
Shandwick Place	Phase 1a
Princes Street	Phase 1a		Princes Street National Gallery of Scotland
St Andrew Square	Phase 1a	Lothian Buses Edinburgh Bus Station Waverley Station	St Andrew Square St. James Centre
Picardy Place	Phase 1a		Omni Centre Edinburgh Playhouse
McDonald Road	Phase 1a		Easter Road Stadium
Balfour Street	Phase 1a		Pilrig Park
Foot of the Walk	Phase 1a	Lothian Buses
Bernard Street	Phase 1a
Port of Leith (formerly Ocean Drive)	Phase 1a		Scottish Government building
Ocean Terminal	Phase 1a		Ocean Terminal Royal Yacht Britannia
Newhaven	Phase 1a		Newhaven
Lower Granton	Phase 2
Granton (formerly Granton Square)	Phase 1b
Saltire Square (formerly Granton Waterfront)	Phase 1b
Caroline Park	Phase 1b		Edinburgh College (Granton Campus)
West Pilton (formerly West Granton)	Phase 1b
Crewe Toll	Phase 1b	Lothian Buses	Fettes College
Telford road	Phase 1b		Western General Hospital
Craigleith	Phase 1b		Craigleith Retail Park
Ravelston Dykes	Phase 1b		Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art Stewart's Melville College The Mary Erskine School St. George's School
Roseburn	Phase 1b
The line continues to Haymarket to complete the loop

Line 2 (West Edinburgh)

Diagram of Line 2 proposed in 2001

Construction of the new tram depot at Gogar

The temporary Fastlink guided bus

Line 2 would have been an 18-kilometre (11 mi) route from the City Centre out to Edinburgh Airport via Edinburgh Park, with a branch line to Newbridge and a total of 19 stops. The airport route was subsequently incorporated into Phase 1a of the project. The branch to Newbridge is dependent on funding becoming available for Phase 3 of the construction project.

In Phase 1a, from St Andrew Square to Haymarket, a 1.4-mile (2.3 km) line of on-street track integrates with other traffic along Princes Street and Shandwick Place. At Haymarket station, the tram line diverges from the road and runs down a segregated tramway via Haymarket Yards. The Line 1 branch north towards Granton (Phase 1b) would be located at the bridge over Russell Road. The Phase 1a line continues west, past the Haymarket rail depot and Murrayfield Stadium. Trams then move onto a dedicated track running parallel to the Edinburgh-Glasgow railway line, briefly crossing south of the railway to serve Sighthill and Edinburgh Park, before heading north, parallel to the City Bypass to the Gyle. The tramway then passes under the A8 road just the east of the Gogar Roundabout, turns west over green belt land, and then north behind the Hilton Hotel and alongside the Gogar Burn to a terminus within the existing airport bus station.[5]

The planned branch to Newbridge would begin at the Ingliston stop, continuing west past the Royal Highland Showground, before crossing onto the central reservation of the A8. It would then turn south via Ratho Station to rejoin the Glasgow main line. At Harvest Road trams would switch to street-running mode again, sharing the road with traffic to the Newbridge industrial estate before crossing the A89 road and terminating at the Newbridge roundabout.[5]

A preliminary guided bus service along part of the future route of Line 2, Fastlink, opened in December 2004.[6] This concrete track, which ran parallel to the Edinburgh-Glasgow railway line from Saughton to Edinburgh Park, was converted to a tram track, replacing the guided bus service with the tram line.

On 27 September 2007, the Scottish Government announced the cancellation of the Edinburgh Airport Rail Link, a separate project to link mainline rail services to Edinburgh Airport. As an alternative, the government plans that an additional stop is built adjacent to a proposed Gogar railway station be constructed. This newly built rail station and tram stop would provide an interchange on the Fife Circle Line with airport tram services. Costs for this have not been stated and would be in addition to the currently budgeted-for amount.[7]

Name	Phase	Transport Interchange	Serves
Between the city centre and Haymarket, trams run along Line 1.
Haymarket	Phase 1a	Haymarket Lothian Buses Line 1 (North Edinburgh)	Edinburgh International Conference Centre
Murrayfield Stadium	Phase 1a		Murrayfield Stadium
Balgreen	Phase 1a		Edinburgh Zoo
Saughton	Phase 1a
Bankhead	Phase 1a		Stevenson College
Edinburgh Park	Phase 1a	Edinburgh Park	Hermiston Gait retail park
Edinburgh Park Central	Phase 1a		Edinburgh Park
Gyle Centre	Phase 1a		Gyle Shopping Centre
Gogarburn	Phase 1a	Gogar	Royal Bank of Scotland headquarters
Ingliston Park & Ride	Phase 1a	Lothian Buses
Line splits – Edinburgh Airport branch
Edinburgh Airport	Phase 1a		Edinburgh Airport
Newbridge branch
Ingliston West	Phase 3		Royal Highland Showground
Ratho Station	Phase 3
Newbridge South	Phase 3
Newbridge North	Phase 3

Line 3 (South East Edinburgh)

Diagram of Line 3 proposed in 2001

Clerk Street, on the route of Line 3

The proposals also featured a third tram line, which would run from the City Centre to the southern suburbs. The route was not finalised, but proposals indicated a preferred route would cross North Bridge and the Royal Mile, heading south past the University of Edinburgh, along Nicolson Street. An alternative route suggested trams could bypass the congested Nicolson Street and Clerk Street section by turning right into Nicolson Square and heading south along Potterrow. Southbound trams would return to Newington Road via West Preston Street, and a northbound track would run along Causewayside. A segregated track was proposed to cross Cameron Toll, and after crossing the Inch Park, trams would then run down the Old Dalkeith Road towards the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, and finally terminating at Newcraighall railway station park and ride. An extension to Musselburgh was also considered.[8] City councillors also suggested that a route via London Road might be considered as an alternative extension to the network.[9]

Line 3 was not approved by the Scottish Parliament and was not funded. Funding for the line depended on Edinburgh voters agreeing to a congestion charge, which was rejected in the Edinburgh road tolls referendum in 2005. Following the referendum defeat, Edinburgh City Council applied to the Scottish Government for £198 million funding for the line, but this request was turned down.[10] As such, the proposal was put on hold indefinitely and does not form part of the approved phases, but the land needed for the line was protected until at least 2015.[11]

Name	Phase	Transport Interchange	Serves
Waverley station	N/A	Waverley Station Lothian Buses Line 1 (North Edinburgh)
High Street	N/A		Royal Mile
South Bridge	N/A
Nicolson Square	N/A		University of Edinburgh George Square campus
St Patrick Square	N/A
The Meadows	N/A		The Meadows
Newington Road	N/A		Newington
Minto Street	N/A
Newington Station	N/A		Interchange with South Suburban Railway at Newington Station
Craigmillar Park	N/A		University of Edinburgh King's Buildings campus (at some distance)
Cameron Toll	N/A		Cameron Toll Shopping Centre
The Inch	N/A
Moredun	N/A		Moredun
RIE/Bio Medipark	N/A		Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh
Greendykes	N/A		Greendykes
Craigmillar	N/A		Craigmillar
Niddrie	N/A		Niddrie
The Wisp	N/A
Fort Kinnaird	N/A		Fort Kinnaird retail park
Newcraighall	N/A	Newcraighall

Other proposals

The Edinburgh South Suburban Railway (including hypothetically reopened stations) with tram interchanges shown

In addition to the three routes selected by transport planners, other proposals were put forward for inclusion in the tram network. Local campaigning groups have suggested that it would be possible to re-open the Edinburgh South Suburban Railway as an extension to Edinburgh trams.[12] This proposal was rejected by the Scottish Parliament on ground of cost and the line will not be re-opened for the foreseeable future.[13]

References

1. "Scottish Light Rail : is it a "U" Turn?". Light Rail Transit Association. Archived from the original on 27 June 2009. Retrieved 13 January 2010.
2. "Tram Facts 8" (PDF). 2006. Archived from the original (PDF) on 6 October 2011.
3. "Edinburgh Tram (Line One) Bill Environmental Statement" (PDF). City of Edinburgh Council/ Scottish Parliament. Archived from the original (PDF) on 23 April 2010. Retrieved 14 January 2010.
4. "Funding concerns for tram project". BBC News. 24 April 2009. Retrieved 11 January 2010.
5. "Edinburgh Tram (Line Two) Bill Environmental Statement" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 17 December 2009. Retrieved 15 January 2010.
6. "£10.5m bus project comes on track". BBC News. 2 December 2004. Retrieved 5 January 2015.
7. Stevenson, Stewart (27 September 2007). "Edinburgh Airport Rail Link". Scottish Parliament. Archived from the original on 4 May 2007. Retrieved 12 January 2010.
8. "Edinburgh Tram Project Line 3 report". City of Edinburgh Council. 24 February 2004. Retrieved 15 January 2010.
9. "Transport chiefs 'want Edinburgh tram network'". BBC News. 4 March 2010. Retrieved 4 March 2010.
10. Ferguson, Brian (24 March 2005). "Edinburgh's third tram line is dead". Edinburgh Evening News. Retrieved 12 January 2010.
11. Roden, Alan (23 August 2005). "Scotsman.com News". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. Retrieved 21 May 2010.
12. "Reopening the South Sub" (PDF). Transform Scotland. March 2007. Archived from the original (PDF) on 11 August 2011. Retrieved 8 January 2010.
13. "Public Petitions Committee Official Report". Scottish Parliament. 27 January 2009. Archived from the original on 5 June 2011. Retrieved 8 January 2010.